By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
SpartenOmega117 said:
wilco said:
SpartenOmega117 said:
i actually thought nico bellic was pretty good character.



anyone who liked rdr but did not like gta 4 is crazy imo


Why?

RDR was a way better game IMO.


to me they were literally the exact same games. And I mean literally right down to the gameplay. The one big difference was the setting otherwise the shooting, cover system, guns were the same. I don't understand what made RDR much better. To me GTA 4 was a fresh experience, then RDR came along and recycled the same gameplay, same type of side missions, same hill billy charachters (never enjoyed it as much since i thought i was playing the same game), then L.A Noire came along and i didnt even go 2 hours into it.

If by "fresh experience" you mean, exactly the same as GTAIII, GTAVC and GTASA.  That's just my opinion though, as upon purchasing and playing through a good chunk of GTAIV, I couldn't help but feel like I had been here before, followed by extreme bordem and constant car jackings/running things over/crashing. 

However, when I played Red Dead Redemption, I got a brand new feeling.  I could easily tell that GTA was hidden behind the western style but it never bothered me.  I loved every minute of it.  But, I grew up on westerns and own way too many of them today.