theprof00 said:
I was thinking blacksaber, you said you did the assraping, which kind of threw me off. Anyway, I want to get back to your tangle with Linkz. You said something about you possibly being a crazy cop. FF should have picked up right away that you were claiming cop. My beef is that you actually seem doubtful about your role. I don't like the "maybe I'm a crazy cop" bit. BUT, there hasn't been a counter-claim and this would be one of those situations where cop counter-claim is obligatory. I don't like what you said because you shouldn't get a free ride. If Linkz does indeed show up as town, we're in a weird predicament. However, your claim also fits into that part about where you said that someone should investigate prof or (was it ST?), and kill some other players whose names I dont remember. I countered by saying you might be going to kill, to softclaim vig later, to which you responded that I should keep my hole shut.....This kind of makes me think I was close enough to what you were doing that it provoked that reaction. However.... you didn't even investigate either of those two people, am I right? So, it's hard to believe either way what you are or your affiliation. You could indeed be a crazy cop, and that's not something I'd like to test with a lynch. I'm just running myself around in circles now... I'd say we should give it another night. You target another player and see what the result is. And we go from there. The possible outcomes is that you are protected or you are killed. In either case we have a much better idea about who to go after. Additionally, I am a little surprised that linkz hasn't prodded me further.. This may come down to a coin flip. |
I wasn't expecting ioi either, because once again I fail to see how that is random.
I don't like the "crazy cop" bit either, because I have a slight feeling it was suggested as a pre-emptive defense in case I'm lynched for when I flip town. It's not necessary for someone else to claim cop though for hat to be Insane, as the presense of a Tracker, Watcher, LD, Thief, etc. would also support the "weakening" of a traditional cop. If there is a cop counter-claim they should step forward, but I'm not asking for anyone to come out as one of those roles. Simply asking that they keep that in mind.
If hat changed his mind from investigating you or ST, it would make sense given the suspicion voiced during twilight. I'm not questioning his choice of me as a target, though that could have been a set up.
Given no protection role(s) is already dead, I would normally disagree with not testing the claim today; however, since I know I am town that would be problematic. I think the idea of giving hat another night is best. You haven't mentioned the possibility of a scum roleblocker, but since nobody has claimed to be roleblocked, there's a good chance they don't have one. hat is a shoe-in for protection as the only claimed power, so it's unlikely he'll be killed.
As for me prodding you more, I usually wait til later with you because I always have such trouble reading you. The only interactions that haven't sat well with me were the ones between yourself and hat earlier. I currently have a town read, and your caution of hat's claim only enforces that further. I also think I have the scumteam pegged, in ST, sabby, and Heph(unmentioned until now, but I'll explain in the next post) so I haven't looked too strongly at anyone else.
