VGC Mafia Round 24

[theprof00]

TruckOSaurus said:

theprof00 said:

good to know, anyway, here's the rest of the stuff i found: Please forgive the titling, it's how I remember one post from another.

Trucks:

trucks strange coincidence
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3822781
"So given the choice to kill Final-Fan, hatmoza, zexen, Hephaestos, theprof00 or nordlead, the Mafia chose Heph. It's possible that there is a reason why he was the unlucky winner of this death lottery other than his record in previous games."

(1) In fact, I don't suspect any of those people. Strange that my suspect would mirror my own opinions.

 

trucks confirms my list?
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3826517

another interesting one. In this one, he draws suspicion on people that I have a hard time believing are mafia.

Truck's timing
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3825660
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3826484

(2) In the first post, I was still suspicious of scottie. Here Scottie posted, and although Truck's had barely said anything, immediately popped up. It looked like a message mafia-to-mafia.

(3) The second post popped up immediately after Radish made a foolish decision to ask what people the cop should investigate. This completely reminded me of when Homer cleared me a couple games ago by saying, "you're not listening to me! I DO NOT SUSPECT THEPROF AT ALL". Hatmoza and dtewi were the only people that commented on it, while most of town knew not to even whisper it again. Eerily enough, the other person to comment on radishes post was stefl. Keep in mind that both of these players had not posted for a while and then were the first two to comment. Very suspect.

70% mafia

 

1) It wasn't a list of pro-town people, it was a list of high profile players. Furthermore I find it quite disarming that you'd feel suspicious of someone for coming to the same conclusion as you did.
               
2) I had said plenty before I replied to scottie. I don't know where you're getting that I "popped up".
               
3) Are you saying you think radishhead is the cop and openly asked for advice on who to investigate? That thought never crossed my mind, radish knows better than to do a move like this.

 

TruckOSaurus said:

1) It wasn't a list of pro-town people, it was a list of high profile players. Furthermore I find it quite disarming that you'd feel suspicious of someone for coming to the same conclusion as you did.

               
2) I had said plenty before I replied to scottie. I don't know where you're getting that I "popped up".
               
3) Are you saying you think radishhead is the cop and openly asked for advice on who to investigate? That thought never crossed my mind, radish knows better than to do a move like this.

1) The actual reason why I found this suspicious was 2-fold. The fact that you came to the same conclusion, but also, the exact list of people you used. My own list of people to off on day 1 would be much much smaller, first of all, and consist of the players who I'd think are most dangerous.

Linkz or Heph. Linkz, I'm scared of, I hope when he's mafia it will be easy to tell. Heph is just a scary player.

Secondly, I'm wondering why you didn't include linkz, yourself, or vette, or others.

To extrapolate, you said:

"He mentions two times that we shouldn't look at Heph's posts because he was probably killed because he's a good player. That may have been the main reason why he was killed but it's not like the town is lacking in good, experienced players.

So given the choice to kill Final-Fan, hatmoza, zexen, Hephaestos, theprof00 or nordlead, the Mafia chose Heph. It's possible that there is a reason why he was the unlucky winner of this death lottery other than his record in previous games."

 

What I see here is a list of good, experienced players. You leave many off that list; your reasoning is lost to me.

The reasoning that I can INFER however, is that you are mafia and that list is all townies. I remember when I was mafia, I also made similar lists so that when I died, people would see my flip result, and then re-read my posts and stumble upon the names of players I was buddying with leading to a strong chance of mislynch.

Anyways, it is completely conjecture. Gniz would call this "twisting your words", but it is an ASSUMPTION. IF you are mafia, then the post says one thing, and if you are town, the post says another. This linked post of yours is not strong evidence in the slightest, I admit. It simply jumps out at me.

 

2) You did pop up. You were the first post after his post, and your last post had been many hours previously. Perhaps you were just skimming, or hadn't seen anything worth replying to, or perhaps it was sheer coincidence. Again, it jumps out at me.

 

3) No, I'm not saying that. I'm saying that he may have inadvertently come off as such, causing instant response from people lurking.