By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Words Of Wisdom said:
SciFiBoy said:

READ MY POST IN FULL, THAT IS NOT WHAT I SAID

I said that we should consider the risk of being wrong in any lynch we attempt, if we have good reasons why a person might be mafia then that reduces the risk attached to lynching them, the question is, are the reasons to vote hatmoza enough to sufficiently reduce (in our individual judgements) the risk of lynching him?

my answer is that currently, no, those reasons do not sufficently reduce the risk for me to vote for him. (im not saying I dont suspect him, im saying I dont suspect him enough to lynch him, yet alone start a small crusade to acheive that lynch)

Do you realize that many mafia games are played with only a cop or only a doctor... and nothing else?

In regular mafia, you're never certain someone is mafia.  There's always the possibility of being wrong however whether you're wrong or right, you learn from that and base your reasoning off of it.  Either way, you can learn something.

Here's how I see things going if we don't lynch:

Day 1:  No Lynch
Day 2:  Cop - WoW is innocent!
Day 2:  Everyone else - We don't have enough evidence to lynch anyone ?????

We're heading to exactly the same position tomorrow as we are today only with me as confirmed pro-town and one or more dead townies.

I'd rather lynch someone today and get a sense of who said what during Day 1 so we actually have stuff to go on tomorrow.

so, you quote my post, so you can ignore what it says?

I didnt say we should only lynch people we are certain are mafia, I know we are never certain

I said we should weigh up the risk of lynching someone vs how supsicous they are, its a judgement call, we each judge whether we are suspicious enough of a player before we decide to vote for him

hell, I even say these things in the post you quoted?

why do people not read my posts? or at least not read them fully or say I said things that I deliberatley avoided saying...