By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
zexen_lowe said:
SciFiBoy said:
zexen_lowe said:

The point is, we (or, rather, I) think he's mafia, not town. But we know that, in the case he's town, his role is less useful than others.

so, you are happy to take that risk? granted its a risk with lynching anyone, but on the first day that risk is even higher, factor in hatmoza normally playing like this, that risk goes higher again, tell me what brings that risk down, if you give me enough things that do, I will consider voting hatmoza

so far I only have 1, his over defensiveness earlier in the game, that said, plenty of people have done that in the past and turned out both pro and anti town

Going with that way of thinking, you'd never lynch anyone, ever. No, I'm not sure hatmoza is mafia, I can't be ever, but if you lynched only when you're 100% sure, almost every night would end with No Lynch. I don't know what do you need, and I'm not trying to swing your vote (nor care to), I already said why I think hatmoza is mafia, and why even if he isn't mafia his loss isn't a huge blow for the town at all, if that's enough for you, you can vote him, if it's not, find someone else who you think it's suspicious.

READ MY POST IN FULL, THAT IS NOT WHAT I SAID

I said that we should consider the risk of being wrong in any lynch we attempt, if we have good reasons why a person might be mafia then that reduces the risk attached to lynching them, the question is, are the reasons to vote hatmoza enough to sufficiently reduce (in our individual judgements) the risk of lynching him?

my answer is that currently, no, those reasons do not sufficently reduce the risk for me to vote for him. (im not saying I dont suspect him, im saying I dont suspect him enough to lynch him, yet alone start a small crusade to acheive that lynch)