By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Words Of Wisdom said:
Final-Fan said:
Vetteman94 said:
Hello everyone, Here is one observation I found that was a little interesting.

I hate bringing up past games but it can give a little insight into peoples normal habits. Of the few games I have played with WoW, she has always suggested no lynch for the first day. Since it almost always gives the town an extra day to lynch an anti-town member when you have more information available to you. She has even provided a table to prove it, and that reasoning is completely sound, as it does work in the towns favor.

So why is she pushing to have a forced lynch on the first day? Why force a blind lynch with little to no information and hoping that someone will slip up on a day one. One thing that never really happens.

Not to mention that I am always a little suspicious of people who try and take control of the game early on, which is another thing she is trying to do.

FoS: WoW

This is excellent, exactly the sort of thing I was wondering about but couldn't remember.  I second this. 

My table in the past is based on the idea that there's one mafia kill per night and one town lynch during the day.  So 2 deaths maximum means that the game will end on a certain day regardless of whether or not that first night ends in a lynch.  However, in a game as large this you can't possibly believe there will be only 2 deaths per night.  We have no idea of knowing what day the game will end on thus we don't know whether a "No Lynch" on Day 1 will matter or not.  Making the same assumptions is a bad idea.

Since the last mafia game I played, I've "leveled up" a few times and learned quite a bit more about the game.  Dialog is key, connections are key, and anyone not providing conversation or actively scum hunting is a liability to the town.  Right now hatmoza isn't scumhunting, he isn't helping the town, he's going "Shoot a lurker instead of me just cuz."  Not only does that make him just as bad as a lurker but it scummy behavior in and of itself.

You don't like the lurker plan, say so. But don't mark me as scummy because of that. This is what I have to offer. It's ironic because you want everyone to contribute but you don't consider that contribution.

 



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson