Onyxmeth said:
Why would LBP be the success? Isn't it relatively on par with Wii Music saleswise? The way Malstrom thinks is that the large evergreen titles that go on to sell countless millions are the successes. This is where he thinks UGC centered titles don't belong. Is a UGC title going to anchor a fall lineup for Nintendo or Sony? Wii Music and LBP didn't do a good job of it. I think Malstrom's always on the big picture, and I'm sure if some third parties were making games like Wii Music and LBP and getting some moderate success on them, he wouldn't care. His attention is on the decisions of the big three and to be honest Miyamoto does seem to have his head wrapped around the idea of UGC a little more than is comfortable if you're someone that is against the idea, like Malstrom is. |
Edit: I missed your point. From Sony and Microsoft's perspective, and game like LBP sold just fine, and I don't see why it wouldn't be enough to anchor a holiday line up in the future. Just look at Uncharted 2's first week. Will it be a system seller? Unless it's making its first appearance on the ps4, likely not. But it'll keep console owners happy, to be sure.
The successes you're describing are few and far between. And I don't see why UGC might inhibit such titles, provided it is primarily an additional feature. It is the gameplay that makes Super Mario sell like it does. Adding an editor and levels accessible via the internet would only add to the normal story mode.
@avinashi: Comparing anything to Super Mario is unfair.