By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Official Thread – The 13th Annual Greatest Games Event *FINISH YOUR LISTS*

1 Chrono Trigger SNES
2 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Switch
3 Super Smash Bros. Brawl Wii
4 StarCraft: Brood War PC
5 Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past SNES
6 Final Fantasy VII PS1
7 Diablo II: Lord of Destruction PC
8 Metroid Prime GC
9 Resident Evil 4 GC/Wii
10 Final Fantasy VI SNES
11 Metal Gear Solid PS1
12 Super Mario 64 N64
13 Final Fantasy X PS2
14 Final Fantasy IV SNES
15 Super Mario Galaxy 2 Wii
16 Super Metroid SNES
17 Hades Switch
18 The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds 3DS
19 Overwatch PC
20 Hollow Knight Switch
21 Donkey Kong Country Returns Wii
22 Super Mario Odyssey Switch
23 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night PS1
24 Secret of Mana SNES
25 Super Mario Bros. 3 NES
26 Super Mario 3D World SNES
27 Mario Kart: Double Dash GC
28 Super Mario World SNES
29 Metroid Dread Switch
30 Resident Evil 2 PS1
31 Diablo III: Reaper of Souls PC
32 Donkey Kong Country SNES
33 Celeste Switch
34 Super Mario Galaxy Wii
35 Xenoblade Chronicles 2 Switch
36 Resident Evil 2 (2019) PS4
37 Tekken Tag Tournament PS2
38 Mario Kart 64 N64
39 Uncharted 2: Among Thieves PS3
40 Super Castlevania IV SNES
41 Tenchu: Stealth Assassins PS1
42 Mega Man X4 PS1
43 Super Punch Out!! SNES
44 Battletoads NES
45 Resident Evil 5 PS3
46 Ori and the Will of the Wisps PC
47 Devil May Cry 5 PS4
48 Resident Evil Village PC
49 Ultra Street Fighter 4 PC
50 Tales of Arise PC
Last edited by TruckOSaurus - on 04 January 2023

Signature goes here!

Around the Network

My 50 greatest games of all time - 2022 edition

I'll link the titles to posts that explain more about the game. The platform contains the platform (or platforms) I played said game on, it may have been released on others. As I can't remember for all which year I played it, the year is the year of release of the game.

title platform year creator
1. Elden Ring Xbox Series 2022 From Software
2. Pandora's Tower Wii 2011 Ganbarion
3. Katamari Damacy PS2/Switch/Stadia 2004 Namco
4. Heroes of Might and Magic III Windows 1999 New World Computing/3DO
5. Tokyo Mirage Sessions ♯FE WiiU/Switch 2016 Atlus
6. Dragon Quest Builders 2 Switch 2018 SquareEnix
7. Wizardry: Tale of the Forsaken Land PS2 2001 Racjin/Atlus
8. Etrian Odyssey Untold: The Millennium Girl 3DS 2013 Atlus/NIS America
9. Ōkami PS2/Wii/Switch 2006 Clover Studio/Capcom
10. Star Wars: Dark Forces DOS 1995 LucasArts
11. Xenoblade Chronicles Wii/Switch 2010 Monolith Soft/Nintendo
12. Demon's Souls PS3 2009 From Software/Sony
13. Another Code: R – A Journey into Lost Memories Wii 2009 Cing
14. Baldur's Gate Windows/Switch 1998 BioWare/Black Isle Studios/Interplay Entertainment
15. Octopath Traveler Switch/Stadia 2018 Square Enix
16. Kid Icarus: Uprising 3DS 2012 Sora/Nintendo
17. Day of the Tentacle DOS 1993 LucasArts
18. The Secret of Monkey Island DOS 1990 LucasArts
19. Baldur’s Gate III Stadia 2020 Larian Studios
20. Fire Emblem Awakening 3DS 2012 Intelligent Systems/Nintendo
21. Return to Zork DOS 1993 Activision/Infocom
22. Deus Ex: Human Revolution WiiU 2011 Eidos/Square Enix
23. Jagged Alliance DOS 1995 Madlab Software/Sir-Tech
24. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Switch 2017 Nintendo
25. UFO: Enemy Unknown DOS 1994 Mythos Games/MicroProse
26. A Short Hike Switch/Linux 2019 Adam Robinson-Yu
27. Graveyard Keeper Switch/Linux/Xbox One 2018 Lazy Bear Games/tinyBuild
28. Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn Wii 2007 Intelligent Systems/Nintendo
29. Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth 3DS 2014 Atlus
30. Wildermyth Linux 2021 Worldwalker Games
31. Romance of the Three Kingdoms XIV Switch 2020 Koei Tecmo
32. Grounded Xbox Series 2022 Obsidian Entertainment/Xbox Game Studios
33. Attack of the Friday Monsters! 3DS 2013 Millenium Kitchen/Aquria/Level-5
34. Odd Realm Linux 2019 Unknown Origin Games
35. Starcraft/Brood War Windows 1998 Blizzard Entertainment
36. Resident Evil: Revelations 3DS/WiiU/Switch 2012 Capcom
37. Pillars of Eternity Linux/Switch 2015 Obsidian Entertainment/Paradox Interactive
38. King’s Bounty II Switch 2021 1C Entertainment
39. Phoenix Point Stadia 2019 Snapshot Games
40. The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask 3DS 2000 Nintendo
41. Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana Switch/Stadia 2016 Nihon Falcom/NIS America
42. Valkyria Chronicles 4 Switch/Stadia 2018 Sega
43. Supaplex DOS 1991 Think!Ware Development/Dream Factory/Digital Integration
44. Crusader Kings III Xbox Series 2020 Paradox
45. Doom 64 Switch/Stadia 1997 Midway
46. The Battle for Wesnoth Linux 2005 David White and The Battle for Wesnoth Project
47. Project Zomboid Linux 2013 The Indie Stone
48. The Elder Scrolls Online Stadia/Xbox Series 2014 Zenimax Online Studios/Bethesda
49. Deathloop Xbox Series 2021 Arkane/Bethesda
50. Descent DOS 1995 Parallax Software/Interplay

 

Here some statistics. As I played some games on multiple platforms, the platform numbers will add up to more than 50. As creators I list only these, which made multiple games I like.

  entries highest
platforms
Switch 17 #3 Katamari Damacy
DOS 8 #10 Star Wars: Dark Forces
Stadia 8 #3 Katamari Damacy
3DS 7 #8 Etrian Odyssey Untold: The Millennium Girl
Linux 7 #26 A Short Hike
Xbox Series 5 #1 Elden Ring
Wii 5 #2 Pandora's Tower
PS2 3 #3 Katamari Damacy
Windows 3 #4 Heroes of Might and Magic III
WiiU 3 #5 Tokyo Mirage Sessions ♯FE
PS3 1 #12 Demon's Souls
Xbox One 1 #27 Graveyard Keeper
decades
90s 12 #4 Heroes of Might and Magic III
00s 8 #3 Katamari Damacy
10s 22 #2 Pandora's Tower
20s 8 #1 Elden Ring
creators
Nintendo 6 #11 Xenoblade Chronicles
Atlus 4 #5 Tokyo Mirage Sessions ♯FE
Square Enix 3 #6 Dragon Quest Builders 2
LucasArts 3 #10 Star Wars: Dark Forces
From Software 2 #1 Elden Ring
NIS 2 #8 Etrian Odyssey Untold: The Millennium Girl
Capcom 2 #9 Ōkami
Bethesda 2 #48 The Elder Scrolls Online
Paradox 2 #37 Pillars of Eternity
Obsidian 2 #32 Grounded
Intelligent Systems 2 #20 Fire Emblem Awakening
Interplay 2 #14 Baldur's Gate

This years honorable mentions:

  • Balrum (2016, Linux)
  • No Man's Sky (2016, Xbox Series)
  • Diablo (1997, Windows)
  • Cities: Skylines (2015, Xbox One)
  • Falling Skies (2014, WiiU)
  • Brigandine: The Legend of Runersia (2020, Switch)

The results of the guessing game can be found here.

Last edited by Mnementh - on 10 January 2023

3DS-FC: 4511-1768-7903 (Mii-Name: Mnementh), Nintendo-Network-ID: Mnementh, Switch: SW-7706-3819-9381 (Mnementh)

my greatest games: 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023

10 years greatest game event!

bets: [peak year] [+], [1], [2], [3], [4]

Rank Game Developer Year (NA) Platform
#50 Castlevania 2: Simon's Quest Konami 1988 NES
#49 Warlords Atari 1980 Atari 2600
#48 Star Wars: X-Wing LucasArts 1993 PC
#47 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night Konami 1997 PlayStation
#46 GoldenEye 007 Rare 1997 N64
#45 Baseball Stars SNK 1989 NES
#44 The Secret of Monkey Island Lucasfilm Games 1990 PC
#43 Golf Story Sidebar Games 2017 Switch
#42 Blaster Master Sunsoft 1988 NES
#41 What Remains of Edith Finch Giant Sparrow 2017 XSX
#40 Super Mario Odyssey Nintendo 2017 Switch
#39 Star Wars: TIE Fighter LucasArts 1994 PC
#38 Oxenfree Night School Studio 2016 PC
#37 Rollercoaster Tycoon Chris Sawyer 1999 PC
#36 NHL '94 EA Sports 1993 Genesis
#35 SimCity 2000 Maxis 1993 PC
#34 The Outer Worlds Obsidian Entertainment 2019 XSX
#33 Super Mario Bros 3 Nintendo 1990 NES
#32 Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Respawn Entertainment 2019 XSX
#31 Yakuza: Like a Dragon Sega 2020 XSX
#30 Mike Tyson's Punch Out Nintendo 1987 NES
#29 Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar Origin Systems 1990 NES
#28 Deus Ex Ion Storm 2000 PC
#27 Tetris Effect: Connected Monstars/Resonair 2020 XSX
#26 Tecmo Super Bowl Tecmo 1991 NES
#25 Ori and the Blind Forest Moon Studios 2015 PC
#24 Legend of Zelda Nintendo 1987 NES
#23 SimCity 4 Maxis 2003 PC
#22 Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker Nintendo 2002 GC
#21 Sid Meier's Civilization II MicroProse 1996 PC
#20 Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess Nintendo 2006 Wii
#19 Ori and the Will of the Wisps Moon Studios 2020 XSX
#18 Half-Life Valve 1998 PC
#17 Metroid Dread Nintendo/MercurySteam 2021 Switch
#16 Steamworld Dig 2 Image & Form 2017 Switch
#15 Mass Effect BioWare 2007 X360
#14 Super Metroid Nintendo 1994 SNES
#13 Super Mario Galaxy Nintendo 2007 Wii
#12 Portal Valve 2007 PC
#11 Mass Effect 3 BioWare 2012 X360
#10 Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past Nintendo 1991 SNES
#9 Super Mario Galaxy 2 Nintendo 2010 Wii
#8 Hades Supergiant Games 2020 Switch
#7 Mass Effect 2 BioWare 2010 X360
#6 Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Nintendo 2017 Switch
#5 Nier: Automata Platinum Games 2017 XSX
#4 Half-Life 2 Valve 2004 PC
#3 Hollow Knight Team Cherry 2017 Switch
#2 Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Nintendo 1998 N64
#1 Portal 2 Valve 2011 PC
Last edited by kenjab - on 31 December 2022

Switch: SW-3707-5131-3911
XBox: Kenjabish

  
Rank Game Platform Year
#50 Battlefield 4 PS4 2013
#49 Quest 64 Nintendo 64 1998
#48 Folklore PS3 2003
#47 The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing III Xbox Series X 2015
#46 Pokemon X 3DS 2013
#45 Super Street Fighter II Super NES 1994
#44 Warhammer 40,000:Inquisitor - Martyr Xbox Series X 2018
#43 The Elder Scrolls V Skyrim PS3, PS4, Xbox One X, Xbox Series X 2011, 2016
#42 Ninja Gaiden  NES 1988
#41 Warhammer: Chaosbane Xbox Series X 2019
#40 Dragon Ball Z: Sagas Gamecube 2005
#39 Super Mario Bros. 3 NES 1990
#38 Mortal Kombat: Deadly Alliance Xbox 2002
#37 Untold Legends: Dark Kingdom PS3 2006
#36 Luigi's Mansion Gamecube 2001
#35 Brutal Legend PS3 2009
#34 Super Mario World Super NES 1990
#33 Rocket League PS4, Xbox Series X 2015
#32 Assassin's Creed Origins Xbox Series X 2017
#31 Max Payne Xbox 2001
#30 Double Dragon NES 1988
#29 Devil Dice PS1 1998
#28 Final Fantasy XV Xbox One X, Xbox Series X 2016
#27 Mario Cart 64 Nintendo 64 1997
#26 Halo 3 Xbox 360 2007
#25 The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past Super NES 1992
#24 The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Xbox 360 2006
#23 Halo 2 Xbox, Xbox Series X 2004
#22 Super Mario 64 Nintendo 64 1996
#21 The Legend of Zelda NES 1986
#20 Borderlands 3 Xbox Series X 2020
#19 Zelda 2: The Adventure of Link NES 1988
#18 Player Unknown's Battlegrounds Xbox One X 2017
#17 Halo: Combat Evolved Xbox, Xbox One, Xbox Series X 2001, 2014
#16 Borderlands 2 PS3, Xbox Series X 2012
#15 Sacred 2: Fallen Angel PS3, Xbox Series X 2012
#14 Fallout 4 Xbox One X, Xbox Series X 2015
#13 Yakuza: Like a Dragon Xbox Series X 2020
#12 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Switch 2017
#11 Champions: Return to Arms PS2 2005
#10 Champions of Norrath PS2 2004
#9 Borderlands Xbox 360, PS3, Xbox One X, Series X 2009,2019
#8 Silent Hill PS1 1999
#7 Shadow Man Dreamcast 1999
#6 No Man's Sky PS4, Xbox Series X 2016
#5 Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance II PS2, Xbox 2001
#4 Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance PS2, Gamecube, Xbox Series X 2001
#3 Minecraft PS4, Xbox Series X 2011
#2 Diablo III PS3, PS4, Xbox One X, Series X 2013
#1 The Elder Scrolls Online PS4, Xbox One X, Series X 2015
Last edited by DroidKnight - on 18 November 2022

...to avoid getting banned for inactivity, I may have to resort to comments that are of a lower overall quality and or beneath my moral standards.

Rank Game Developer Original Year* Platform played on
50 Bayonetta Platinum Games 2009 Xbox 360
49 Halo Wars Ensemble Studios 2009 Xbox 360
48 Dante's Inferno Visceral Games 2010 Xbox 360
47 Megadimension Neptunia VII Idea Factory/Compile Heart 2015 PS4
46 God of War  Sony 2005 PS2
45 Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back Naughty Dog 1997 PS1
44 Titanfall 2 Respawn 2016 PS4
43 Xenoblade Chronicles 2 Monolith Soft/Nintendo 2017 Nintendo Switch
42 Halo Combat Evolved Bungie 2001 Xbox
41 Lost Odyssey Mistwalker/Feelplus 2008 Xbox 360
40 Call of Duty World at War Treyarch 2008 Xbox 360
39 Overwatch Blizzard 2016 Xbox One
38 Forza Horizon Playground Games 2012 Xbox 360
37 Mass Effect 3 BioWare 2012 Xbox 360
36 Titanfall Respawn 2014 Xbox One
35 Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Treyarch 2012 Xbox 360
34 Halo 4 343 industries 2012 Xbox 360
33 God of War (2018) Sony 2018 PS4
32 Bioshock Infinite Irrational Games 2013 Xbox 360
31 Grand Theft Auto V Rockstar Games 2013 Xbox 360
30 Mass Effect BioWare 2007 Xbox 360
29 Persona 4 Golden Atlus 2012 PC
28 Final Fantasy VII Square 1997 PS4
27 Dragon Quest XI Square Enix 2018 PS4
26 Burnout Revenge Criterion Games 2004 PS2
25 Jade Empire BioWare 2005 Xbox
24 Tales of Berseria Bandai Namco 2016 PS4
23 Devil Survivor 2 Atlus 2009 3DS
22 Halo 3 Bungie 2007 Xbox 360
21 Grand Theft Auto Vice City Rockstar Games 2002 PS2
20 Modern Warfare 2 Infinity Ward 2009 Xbox 360
19 Nier Automata Platinum Games/Square Enix 2017 PS4
18 Assassins Creed II Ubisoft Montreal 2009 Xbox 360
17 Fire Emblem Awakening Intelligent Systems/Nintendo 2013 3DS
16 The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel III Nihon Falcom 2019 PS4
15 Halo 2 Bungie 2004 Xbox
14 Final Fantasy VII Remake Square Enix 2020 PS4
13 Persona 5 Royal Atlus 2016 PS4
12 Xenoblade Chronicles DE Monolith Soft/Nintendo 2020 Nintendo Switch
11 The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel Nihon Falcom 2015 PS4
10 Xenoblade Chronicles 3 Monolith Soft/Nintendo 2022 Nintendo Switch
9 Final Fantasy X Square Enix 2001 PS2
8 Mass Effect 2 BioWare 2010 Xbox 360
7 Resident Evil 4 Capcom 2005 PS2
6 Fire Emblem Three Houses Intelligent Systems/Nintendo 2019 Nintendo Switch
5 Witcher 3 Wild Hunt CD Project Red 2015 Xbox One
4 The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel II Nihon Falcom 2016 PS4
3 Devil Survivor Atlus 2009 3DS
2 The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel IV Nihon Falcom 2020 PS4
1 Persona 3 FES Atlus 2007 PS2

* North American release year

Last edited by NobleTeam360 - on 07 December 2022

Around the Network

Rank Game Platform(s) I've played it on Developer YoY My Rating
#50 Grandia II PC Game Arts -9 8.8/10
#49 Uncharted 2: Among Thieves PS3, PS4 Naughty Dog -5 8.9/10
#48 A Plague Tale: Innocence PS4 Asobo Studio -6 8.9/10
#47 God of War (2018) PS4 Santa Monica Studio +2 8.9/10
#46 Suikoden II PS1 Konami -3 8.9/10
#45 The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky the 3rd PC Nihon Falcom -5 9.0/10
#44 Lost Odyssey Xbox 360 Mistwalker -5 9.0/10
#43 Enslaved: Odyssey to the West PS3 Ninja Theory -6 9.0/10
#42 Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch PS3 Level-5 -7 9.0/10
#41 Kingdom Hearts II PS2 Square Enix -7 9.0/10
#40 Okami PS2, PS4 Clover Studio -4 9.0/10
#39 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Switch Nintendo EPD -1 9.1/10
#38 Super Mario Bros. 3 NES Nintendo R&D4 -7 9.1/10
#37 Spiritfarer PS4 Thunder Lotus Games NEW 9.1/10
#36 Journey PS3, PS4 Thatgamecompany -6 9.1/10
#35 Total Annihilation PC Cavedog Entertainment -6 9.1/10
#34 Stardew Valley PC ConcernedApe -2 9.1/10
#33 Tales of Berseria PS4 Bandai Namco Studios = 9.1/10
#32 The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel III PS4 Nihon Falcom -4 9.2/10
#31 The Last of Us Part II PS4 Naughty Dog NEW 9.2/10
#30 Valkyria Chronicles 4 PS4 Sega, Media.Vision NEW 9.2/10
#29 Yakuza 0 PS4 Ryu Ga Gotoku Studio -3 9.2/10
#28 Persona 4 PS2 Atlus -3 9.2/10
#27 Grandia PS1 Game Arts -3 9.2/10
#26 The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel PS3, PS4 Nihon Falcom -3 9.2/10
#25 Final Fantasy VII Remake PS4 Square Enix +2 9.2/10
#24 The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel IV PS4 Nihon Falcom NEW 9.2/10
#23 Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater PS3 Konami -2 9.2/10
#22 Hollow Knight PC, PS4 Team Cherry = 9.3/10
#21 The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel II PS3, PS4 Nihon Falcom -1 9.3/10
#20 Nier: Automata PS4 PlatinumGames -1 9.3/10
#19 Final Fantasy VII PS1 Squaresoft -1 9.3/10
#18 Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin PS3 FromSoftware -4 9.3/10
#17 Final Fantasy VI SNES Squaresoft = 9.3/10
#16 Horizon Zero Dawn PS4 Guerrilla Games = 9.3/10
#15 Final Fantasy VIII PS1 Squaresoft = 9.3/10
#14 Uncharted 4: A Thief's End PS4 Naughty Dog -1 9.3/10
#13 The Last of Us PS3 Naughty Dog -1 9.4/10
#12 Dark Souls III PS4 FromSoftware -3 9.4/10
#11 The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky PC Nihon Falcom = 9.4/10
#10 Elden Ring PS4 FromSoftware NEW 9.5/10
#9 Final Fantasy X PS2, PS3 Squaresoft +1 9.5/10
#8 Bloodborne PS4 FromSoftware = 9.6/10
#7 The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky SC PC Nihon Falcom = 9.6/10
#6 Shadow of the Colossus PS2, PS3, PS4 Team Ico = 9.7/10
#5 Valkyria Chronicles PS3, PS4 Sega = 9.7/10
#4 Dark Souls PS3, PS4 FromSoftware = 9.7/10
#3 Freespace 2 PC Volition = 9.8/10
#2 The Legend of Dragoon PS1 Sony Japan Studio = 9.8/10
#1 Final Fantasy IX PS1, PS4 Squaresoft = 9.9/10

Last edited by Darashiva - on 01 January 2023

Rank Title Platform(s) Developer Year Notes
#50 Joe & Mac (Caveman Ninja) SNES Data East 1991 SNES version, NOT the Arcade version.
#49 Mega Man X4 PS1 Capcom 1997
#48 Red Dead Redemption PS3 Rockstar 2010 Includes DLC: Undead Nightmare
#47 New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe NSW Nintendo 2019 Includes DLC: New Super Luigi U
#46 The Messenger NSW/PS4 Sabotage 2018
#45 Axiom Verge NSW/PS4 ThomasHapp 2015
#44 Demon's Souls PS3/PS5 Fromsoft 2009 Specifically the Remaster on PS5
#43 Terraria NSW/PS4 Re-Logic 2011
#42 Cuphead and the Delicious Last Course NSW/PS4 Studio MDHR 2017 Includes DLC: Delicious Last Course
#41 Yooka-Laylee and the Impossible Lair NSW/PS4 Playtonic 2019
#40 Guitar Hero II PS2 Harmonix 2006 X360 version is better but never played it.
#39 Portal 2 PS3 Valve 2011 Tied with Portal 1, but I had to choose
#38 Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice PS4 Fromsoft 2019
#37 Ratchet & Clank: Up Your Arsenal PS2 Insomniac 2004 Also includes HD Remaster on PS3
#36 Donkey Kong Country SNES Rare 1994
#35 Mega Man X2 SNES Capcom 1995
#34 Resident Evil 4 GCN Capcom 2005 Wii version is better but GCN was first
#33 Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag PS3 Ubisoft 2013 Switch/PS4 versions are better but PS3 was first
#32 The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker GCN Nintendo 2003 WiiU versionis better but GCH was first
#31 Mega Man X3 SNES Capcom 1996
#30 Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island SNES Nintendo 1995
#29 Dark Souls PS3 Fromsoft 2011 PS4/Switch version is better, but PS3 was first
#28 Super Mario Bros. 3 NES Nintendo 1990 The Version in All-Stars is best
#27 Pokemon Red/Blue GB GameFreak 1998 Fire Red/Leaf Green are better
#26 Final Fantasy IX PS1 Squaresoft 2000
#25 Ratchet & Clank: A Crack in Time PS3 Insomniac 2009
#24 Pokemon Black/White DS GameFreak 2011 Please don't muck up the remaster!
#23 God of War PS4 SonySantaMonica 2018 Ragnarok will be tying this, eventually
#22 Mario Kart 8/Deluxe WiiU/NSW Nintendo 2014 Deluxe specifically with the DLC/Expansion
#21 Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart PS5 Insomniac 2021
#20 Final Fantasy VIII PS1 Squaresoft 1999
#19 Mega Man 2 NES Capcom 1988 Oldest game on my list
#18 Dark Souls III PS4 Fromsoft 2016 Includes DLC: Ashes of Ariandel/Ringed City
#17 Super Smash Bros. Ultimate NSW Nintendo 2018 Includes all DLC
#16 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild NSW Nintendo 2017 Includes DLC
#15 Red Dead Redemption II PS4 Rockstar 2018 Includes Red Dead Online
#14 Final Fantasy XII PS2 Square-Enix 2006 The Zodiac Age more specifically
#13 Donkey Kong Country 3: Dixie Kong's Double Trouble SNES Rare 1996
#12 Rock Band 4 PS4 Harmonix 2015 Represents the franchise as a whole
#11 Final Fantasy X PS2 Squaresoft 2001 HD Remaster more specifically
#10 The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim PS3 Bethesda 2011 Special/Anniversary Editions on PS4/5 are better
#9 Final Fantasy VII PS1 Squaresoft 1997 NOT the Remake, though that will be on here too
#8 Elden Ring PS5 Fromsoft 2022 Doesn't even have DLC yet! 
#7 Super Mario World SNES Nintendo 1991
#6 Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy's Kong Quest SNES Rare 1995
#5 Mega Man X SNES Capcom 1994
#4 Bloodborne PS4 Fromsoft 2015 Includes DLC: The Old Hunters
#3 The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past SNES Nintendo 1992
#2 Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars SNES Squaresoft 1996
#1 Final Fantasy VI SNES Squaresoft 1994

Last edited by Runa216 - on 22 November 2022

My Console Library:

PS5, Switch, XSX

PS4, PS3, PS2, PS1, WiiU, Wii, GCN, N64 SNES, XBO, 360

3DS, DS, GBA, Vita, PSP, Android

Here we go!

Rank Game Year System
50 Splatoon 2 NS
49 The Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time GC
48 Far Cry 3 PC
47 Star Wars Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast PC
46 Sonic Colours Wii
45 The Legend of Zelda A Link Between Worlds 3DS
44 Star Wars Battlefront 2 (original) PC
43 Call of Duty 4 Modern Warfare 1 PC
42 Digimon Story: Cyber Sleuth NS
41 Metal Gear Rising Revengeance PC
40 Pokemon Trading Card Game GB
39 Zoo Tycoon+ expansions PC
38 Star Wars Battlefront (original) PC
37 Kirby and The Amazing Mirror GBA
36 Grand Theft Auto San Andreas PC
35 Portal 2 PC
34 Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Bue/Red Team GBA
33 Pokemon X/Y 3DS
32 Mario Kart 8 Deluxe NS
31 Wii Sports Wii
30 Megaman Zero 1 GBA
29 Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald GBA
28 Doom 2016 PC
27 Serious Sam The First Encounter PC
26 Pokemon FirRed/Leafgreen GBA
25 Might and Magic Clash of Heroes DS
24 Sonic Adventure DX Director's Cut PC
23 Fire Emblem Blazing Sword GBA
22 Fallout 3 PC
21 Unreal Tournament 2004 PC
20 Super Smash Brothers Ultimate NS
19 Tetris GB
18 Danganrompa. Trigger Happy Havoc PC
17 Danganrompa 2 Goodbye Despair PC
16 Age of Mythology + Titans expansion PC
15 Sonic Rush DS
14 Chrono Trigger DS
13 Megaman Zero 3 GBA
12 Serious Sam The Second Encounter PC
11 Fire Emblem The Sacred Stones GBA
10 Fire Emblem Awakenig () 3DS
9 The Legend of Zelda The Wind Waker GC
8 Grand Theft Auto Vice City PC
7 Shadow of the Colossus PS2
6 Katawa Shoujo PC
5 Megaman Zero 4 GBA
4 The Elder Scrolls Skyrim PC
3 Age of Empires II + The Conquerors Expansion PC
2 Pokemon Gold/Silver/Crystal GB
1 Pokemon Black/White DS
Last edited by Darwinianevolution - on 30 December 2022

You know it deserves the GOTY.

Come join The 2018 Obscure Game Monthly Review Thread.

Tagging

Rank Title Platform(s) Developer Year Notes
#50 Xenogears  PS1
#49 Final Fantasy 6 SNES
#48 Pokemon Crystal GBC
#47 Final Fantasy X-2 PS2
#46 Diablo 2 PC
#45 GTA: Vice City PS2
#44 Kingdom Hearts PS2
#43 Yakuza: Like A Dragon PS4
#42 Xenosaga: Episode 1 PS2
#41 999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors DS
#40 Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep PS3
#39 Ghost of Tsushima PS4
#38 Suikoden PS1
#37 Lightning Returns: Final Fantasy XIII PS3
#36 Valkyria Chronicles 4 PS4
#35 Capcom vs SNK 2 PS2
#34 Resident Evil 5 PS3 Co-op only.
#33 Final Fantasy X PS2
#32 Devil May Cry PS2
#31 Zero Escape: Virtue’s Last Reward 3DS
#30 Megaman X4 PS1
#29 Resident Evil 2 PS1
#28 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night PS1
#27 Chrono Cross PS1
#26 Mario 64 N64
#25 Secret of Mana SNES
#24 Final Fantasy VII Remake PS4
#23 Elden Ring PS4
#22 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time N64
#21 The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening GB
#20 Final Fantasy 9 PS1
#19 Final Fantasy Tactics PS1
#18 Yakuza 0 PS4
#17 Suikoden 5 PS2
#16 The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask N64
#15 Persona 4 PS2
#14 Persona 3 PS2
#13 Xenosaga: Episode 3 PS2
#12 Shadow Hearts 2 PS2
#11 Shadow Hearts PS2
#10 Metal Gear Solid 3 PS2
#9 Final Fantasy 7 PS1
#8 Final Fantasy 8 PS1
#7 Persona 5 Royal PS4
#6 Nier: Automata PS4
#5 Metal Gear Solid PS1
#4 Shadow Hearts 2 PS2
#3 Resident Evil 4 PS4
#2 Chrono Trigger SNES
#1 Suikoden 2 PS1

Last edited by Hiku - on 30 December 2022

Rank Game Platforms Year
#50 Halo Infinite Xbox Series X 2021
#49 Kingdom Hearts 3  PS4 2019
#48 Borderlands 2  Xbox 360 2012
#47 Fallout 4 Xbox One 2015
#46 Star Wars Galactic Battlegrounds PC 2001
#45 Pokemon Soul Silver DS 2010
#44 Yakuza 0 PS4/XB1 2015
#43 Halo: Combat Evolved Xbox/Xbox One 2001
#42 Pokemon Alpha Sapphire 3DS 2014
#41 Spider-Man PS4 2018
#40 Uncharted 4  PS4 2016
#39 Overwatch PC/PS4/XB1 2016
#38 Yakuza Kiwami 2 Xbox One 2020
#37 Assassin's Creed Syndicate PS4/XB1 2016
#36 Far Cry 3 Xbox 360 2012
#35 Star Wars Battlefront 2 Xbox 2005
#34 Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3 Xbox 360 2011
#33 Dragon Age Inquisition Xbox One 2014
#32 The Outer Worlds Xbox One 2019
#31 Uncharted 3 PS4 2011
#30 Assassin's Creed Odyssey PS4 2018
#29 Fallout New Vegas Xbox 360 2010
#28 Halo 3 ODST Xbox 360/Xbox One 2009
#27 Chrono Trigger SNES/DS 1995
#26 The Witcher 2 Xbox 360 2011
#25 Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 Xbox 360 2009
#24 Tomb Raider (2013) Xbox One 2013
#23 God of War (2018) PS4 2018
#22 Forza Horizon 5 Xbox Series X 2021
#21 Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order PS4 2019
#20 Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon Xbox 360/PC 2013
#19 Sleeping Dogs Xbox 360/XB1/PS4 2012
#18 LA Noire Xbox 360/PS4 2011
#17 Fable 2 Xbox 360 2008
#16 Assassin's Creed 4: Black Flag Xbox 360/Xbox One 2013
#15 Saints Row 4 X360/XB1/PS4/PC 2013
#14 The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim X360/XB1/PS4/PC 2011
#13 Dishonored Xbox 360/Xbox One 2012
#12 Sonic Mania Xbox One 2017
#11 Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic Xbox/PC/iOS 2003
#10 Deus Ex: Human Revolution Xbox 360/PC 2011
#9 Halo 3 Xbox 360/Xbox One 2007
#8 Kingdom Hearts 2 PS2/PS4 2005
#7 Age of Empires 2 PC 1999
#6 Fallout 3 Xbox 360 2008
#5 Sonic 3 & Knuckles Genesis 1994
#4 Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic 2 Xbox/PC 2005
#3 Halo 2 Xbox/Xbox One 2004
#2 Red Dead Redemption Xbox 360 2010
#1 Witcher 3 Xbox One/Xbox Series X 2015

Last edited by shikamaru317 - on 03 January 2023