And same reviewers that gave those scores had no question on which of these 3 was the better game and certainly you think they hold AAA and indies at the same standard when scoring right?

Nobody said they were inferior, we said they don't typically win GotY awards, which they don't.  

I asked a few pages ago and never got an answer.  Name one Indie game that won the most GotY awards in any given year.

Again- Telltale’s Walking Dead- Season 1 won in 2012

Journey finished a close second that year

Walking Dead won more GotY awards than Mass Effect 3, xenoblade, dishonored and persona 4?

Fair enough, then once in a decade occurrence.

Yes- 

This is a year that could be said to be very weak competition.

Fair enough. I'm not even sure what Walking Dead is, never played it.

You said "Comparatively it was [weaker]. The fact you guys are listing Indie and Remakes... basically demonstrates as much." 

That sure sounds as you saying indies and remakes are inferior to other games.

I'm saying they are less likely to win awards. Which I believe previous winners largely support that position.  By "weaker" I'm not talking about quality but competition for awards.  

Personally I think RE2 is one of the best games of the generation.

Blind Forest is the best game on the Xbox.  

I just think most media outlets and consumers are biased towards larger budget games.