X360. I played Alan Wake as my first game, which I bought it for and every other exclusive after that disappointed apart from some fun with Mass effect 2 and Forza. Playstation had built such a level of quality even in it's mediocre games like reaistwnce that it put the 360 to shame. I don't regret buying it though as some third party games around that time were broken on ps3 and it was great to have a place to play games like Skyrim.
Oh.. You didn't rate Halo 3 or Reach? I mean, I would understand 4.. Halo was never the same after Bungie left.