I had a big post typed up and lost it, so this is much shorter than I'd have liked ;o;
#2: Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Time/Darkness/Sky |
Time/Darkness released in 2007, Sky in 2009 on the DS by Chunsoft. |

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers, are the most beautiful games ever made.
They are a grand tale of adventure, perseverance in the face of adversity, personal growth, and doing the right thing in the face of all opposition. As you make your way in a new world, fit into a guild, and eventually get dragged into a conflict that threatens the very fabric of the universe itself.
Their gameplay is incredible, you traverse mystery dungeons, battling and collecting treasure along your way, and also recruiting new members to your team.

The characters and story are where the game truly shines.
The villains all have firm defined objectives, and are easily the darkest characters Pokemon has ever seen. They straight up threaten to kill you, and even attempt to execute you.
Grovyle is the best character in any Pokemon game. It's a strong individual that never gives up in the face of all the obstacles thrown in its way, and always fights for what it believes to be justified.

The guild members themselves are fantastic as well. At first they all appear to be very simple characters, but through dialogue, their development across the game is incredible. My personal favourite is Bidoof, who is a newbie much like yourself, and is depicted as being clumsy and unsure in themself. Over the course of the game, they grow and become a strong asset to the guild.
Much like DQXI S, PMD: Explorers of Sky introduced a plethora of new content to the already fantastic Time/Darkness by way of character episodes that explored guild members' backstories in detail. Bidoof's shows that more than anything - your own perseverance will get you where you want to go in life.
The artstyle is timeless, and they remain the most beautiful looking Pokemon games today. Their soundtrack as well, is absolutely breathtaking - more than 5 hours of masterpiece after masterpiece that sets the atmosphere of every moment throughout the game incredibly well.
If I could give this equal first, I would. If I had played through this year, it would almost certainly still be there in the #1 spot. This is an utterly breathtaking masterpiece of a game that deserves a playthrough from anybody.