So you had 2 options but only one was selectable? Now that's even weirder, because as you can clearly see, this was not the case for me. Incidentally, I did try this twice. Once when it initially went up, and again about 10 days later, so it wasn't some brief aberration. Anyway, glad to have another response from a North American/Canadian, because aside from you and Blood_Tears, all the other people who have responded both on VGC and PSN have all been from the EU, where this change apparently did not occur.
Yup. I think both selections just said Game (not certain) and neither had a price, as if they were the same. It's not like one was faded/grayed out, it just didn't seem to allow selecting the other, which I didn't worry about because I didn't see the difference. Clicked add to library and got the "this game has been added to your library" pop up.