Forums - Gaming Discussion - Wii U vs PS4 vs Xbox One FULL SPECS (January 24, 2014)

tripenfall said:
Mario Kart 8's graphics and frame rate look as good as anything on Xbone IMO


In that case they look as good as anything on PS4. Since a few "Xbone" games do. So, interesting you didn't mention PS4.

But Wii U like Wii before can only "excel" graphically at cartoony games, because the artstyle camuoflages the lack of power. Mario Galaxy looked good last gen compared to PS3/360 games, but The Conduit (realistic FPS) looked not even as good as Doom 3 on 2001 Xbox. Similarly, I doubt Wii U could do Halo 4 as well as 360.

Where Wii U would get exposed is if you tried to port lets say, BF4 to it. That would just get ugly fast.

Anyways it's over, Xbox One has enough power to be "next gen", for example the COD:AW trailer running on it (and looking amazing). Wii U does not.



Around the Network
fallen said:
tripenfall said:
Mario Kart 8's graphics and frame rate look as good as anything on Xbone IMO


In that case they look as good as anything on PS4. Since a few "Xbone" games do. So, interesting you didn't mention PS4.

But Wii U like Wii before can only "excel" graphically at cartoony games, because the artstyle camuoflages the lack of power. Mario Galaxy looked good last gen compared to PS3/360 games, but The Conduit (realistic FPS) looked not even as good as Doom 3 on 2001 Xbox. Similarly, I doubt Wii U could do Halo 4 as well as 360.

Anyways it's over, Xbox One has enough power to be "next gen", for example the COD:AW trailer running on it (and looking amazing). Wii U does not.

Huh? I can't understand what your saying. I know you're defending Xbox, but I don't understand what you're saying or why you bring PS4 into this and I really can't see how you make the jump from MK8 looking as good as anything on the XBone to it looking as good as anything on the PS4, because the PS4 has defintively better looking games than X1, multiplat or exclusive.

I mean even if we take your opinion, simple logic contradicts your own statement.

few "Xbone" games do(look better than PS4) implies Most PS4 games look better than XBone games.

Thus if MK8 looks better than all X1 games, then even if it looks better than few X1 games that beat PS4 games thus beating out those PS4 games, it still only looks as good/better than few PS4 games.

#math

In more abstract terms

q = set of all xb1 games

a = MK8

r = set of all ps4 games

o = set of xb1 games that look better than ps4

p = the corresponding set of ps4 games that look worse than XB1 games

o is a subset of q

a is > q1 for all q

o > p which is a subset of r

thus a > p1 for all p but NOT all r

#logic

#math

#struggle



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

tripenfall said:
Mario Kart 8's graphics and frame rate look as good as anything on Xbone IMO


No it doesn't.



spurgeonryan said:
Two years later. What is this thread about now?

Mostly here just for reference with the occasional random post trying to suggest something in OP is wrong. Though given many lengthy discussions here, gaf, and otherwise all point to this info being very accurate.



superchunk said:
spurgeonryan said:
Two years later. What is this thread about now?

Mostly here just for reference with the occasional random post trying to suggest something in OP is wrong. Though given many lengthy discussions here, gaf, and otherwise all point to this info being very accurate.


Wow! Long time quote.

 

Why do they even try Superchunk.....



    The NINTENDO PACT 2015[2016  Vgchartz Wii U Achievement League! - Sign up now!                      My T.E.C.H'aracter