Forums - Gaming Discussion - Metal Gear Solid 4 vs Super Mario Galaxy. Which is the Greatest??

Papazx said:
im going with mgs4 graphics are amazing story is amazing and gameplay is amazing smg lacks graphics and story

wait, what? mario galaxy's graphics look amazing, best looking wii game, it is not in HD but that dont mean the graphics are bad.



Wii/Mario Kart Wii Code:2793-0686-5434
Around the Network

Without a doubt Metal Gear Solid 4. Better story, Graphics, Very refined. The game was just perfect. Every nook and cranny in that game was given consideration. You can always tell when a game has just had so much TLC dumped into it.  Metal Gear Solid 4 is one of those games. 


I liked Galaxy. One of the few games that I actually have liked. But the Wii mote was practically useless with it. Galaxy was good but I can even begin to describe how far away it was from Mario 64. It had some neat things with gravity. Running around on the different planets and spheres was pretty neat. However, it was 3d Mario in space. It was highly, highly overrated IMO.


Also for the people bagging on the cut scenes in MGS4 and the length of gameplay, Mario Galaxy wasn't exactly the longest game in the world. Like most Mario games you can beat it in a very timely fashion.



Cougarman said:
Papazx said:
im going with mgs4 graphics are amazing story is amazing and gameplay is amazing smg lacks graphics and story

wait, what? mario galaxy's graphics look amazing, best looking wii game, it is not in HD but that dont mean the graphics are bad.

I AGREE the graphics on smg are awesome.

 



SMG.



Hideo Kojima's Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots for the SONY Playstation 3 Computer Entertainment System.



4 ≈ One

Around the Network

between those 2 i would have to go with galaxy. It is the best 3d platformer of all time and had great graphics, music , and production values. It was innovative and still kept what made mario fun in the past with lots of variety and simple fun use of the wii mote. Galaxy 10/10

Metal Gear Solid had graphics, music, and production values also, but without cutscenes i beat the game on normal in 5 and a half hours while galaxy was closer to 25. Also the story sucked in 4 and some horrible dialogue that they would say seriously but i had to believe they were joking and the gameplay was above average but nothing revolutionary or top notch 8.5/10

but i think GTA 4 just edges out Mario Galaxy for game of the generation, definitely now that lost and damned came out



Both amazing truly amazing games.

I'd go with Galaxy for it's originality and replay value.

Galaxy is my fav. game this gen, with MGS4 close behind.



which is better should be the right question. SMG as personal opinion, MGS4 as technical achievements in graphics.

Though, honestly to the original poster, I don't see how MGS4 is a perfect example of how games should be this generation. If i wanted to watch a movie, i would go watch a movie...



Hmm, played both and both sucked, if this was about which sucked more then MGS4 takes the cake.



I'm Unamerica and you can too.

The Official Huge Monster Hunter Thread: 



The Hunt Begins 4/20/2010 =D

MGS4 for me. I had fun playing both games, but it was only with MGS4 that I actually was blown away.