1/ "Killzone has been pretty much overhyped for no reason. It's coming off 2 really bad reviewed and sold games before. And with only a fake trailer"

==> completely right,
the fact is that sony fan still expect to get a "cinematic game like" with great graphism (the E2006 cinematic), it is why there are still a lot of hype in the PS3 community (with Gorillaz saying "they will shut up the critics") but only in the PS3 community

2/ " showing it has no difference than any other shooter out there really the hype is simply coming from the demand for a worse Halo replica on the PS3. That or simply just for a game in any sense."

==> I don't aggry,
you know even if the first Killzone was expected as an halo killer, today, it is not interesting to compare killzone to halo. NOW, Gear of war and Crysis are more hyped game than Halo3 is (except for the Halo fan). Halo is not anymore the only good FPS on console

3/ My point about innovation in FPS,
You know, about Gear of war, what is really new in this game ?
except the cover system that come from another game (dont know the game sorry), where is innovation ?
there is nothing really new in gear of war !!! just another FPS !!!
and it is the same for all these "news" FPS that are just released with upgraded graphism ...
BUT
why is there so many people saying that Gear of WAr is a great game ???
I think it is just because it is a very immersive game that, without innovating a lot, is perfect in all the point (solid gameplay/graphism/sound/IMMERSION)
that is all ...

and look about another gow : GOD OF WAR
what is new in this fucking game ??
why this game is selling so well ??
It is just a fucking beat them all !!
BUT
the graphism are great, good sound, not bad scenario (at least for the 1), very IMMERSIVE game, after 2 mins you already have fun "killing" (lol) everybody around u with your blades.

These 2 games (and others like Halo1) are CINEMATIC game with very IMMERSIVE 3D world. That is all.

Just see Bioshock, just another FPS, same view thant u can play perfectly with a keyboard and a mouse, like all the FPS since more than 10 years !
BUT,
story seems GREAT, graphism are beautifull, some gameplay innovation (but nothing incredible in my point of view like all the FPS since CS),
AND AMAZING IMMERSION !!!

Indeed, the E3 2006 cinematic show us a similar view, a very reallistic immersive epic world that make us think that the game will be wonderfull

Of course, it is was just pre-calculated cinematic, that cannot be considered as in-game footage, but PS3 fan still hope ...

Wait & see !

Left 4 Dead is innovative as hell.

I didnt know Satans dwelling hole was an innovative place.

Little did you know.

I'm not trying to incite any type of massive anti-sony campaign here but just have a question about this game. What does it bring that PS3 that a game like Resistance did not? I'm not trying to knock the game down here or anything but is there something to this game that will make it sell more on the PS3 I know Halo has its past and storyline to draw in all the previous buyers does Killzone have the same thing never played the game? Is it just the graphics that are creating the hype around the game and if this is the case will there be a lack of similar games at the time of its release for gamers to play I mean if there will be I understand it would sell as it would fit into that FPS console player niche but if there won't be wouldn't the more well known franchises sell? Just some questions for those that know haven't really followed this game that much and don't know much about the previous games besides that it isn't on this sites million seller list but some think it should be.

He actually rebutted himself. "Name any Sony game that's actually any good... well except those six games" GT1-4, and GoW1&2, not to mention GT5.... Name any huh?

 Ok, I'll just name Sony published series instead of each title:

Gran Turismo ~ 44.53 million sold

Crash Bandicoot ~ 30.95

Spyro ~ 12.14

SOCOM ~ 8.65

Ratchet and Clank ~ 5.3

not to mention The Getaway, Jak and Daxter, Syphon Filter, Twisted Metal, Sly Cooper... But putting these aside there are NOT ANY good games published by Sony!

Back to topic, I too have high hopes for Killzone 2, some seem to forget that Sony fans are the ones that will be let down the most if something goes fubar, but I think they'll get it right this time.

Bad reviewed, really? I enjoyed them and a few others did too... 

Killzone: Liberation on PSP from metacritic.com

All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...

95

Deeko

Without a shadow of a doubt, one of the most highly-polished and brag-worthy games that the PSP has.

91

Game Chronicles

Liberation is a perfect example of just how powerful the PSP is, and a great way to experience console action in the palm of your hand.

90

Ferrago

One of the most pleasing things about Killzone Liberation that it seems to have been polished to the point you can almost see your face in it, it's impeccably balanced, looks amazing and is full of little gameplay touches and ideas that only come when a game has been developed by people who truly care about it.

90

Worth Playing

A must-own title that is definitely worth playing. Everything is great, and I really cannot think of anything I would change about what could be this year's greatest hand-held game.

90

PGNx Media

The worst thing that can be said about Killzone: Liberation is that we want more of it. We would have liked a longer single-player experience and we would have liked online multiplayer, but the gameplay in the game is so well done that you would be doing yourself a disservice if you let that stop you from getting the game. Action games do not get much better on the PSP.

90

DarkStation

After the over-hyped console version, the handheld port fortunately delivers with a perfect blend of solid controls and challenging levels.

90

IGN

It seems wherever Liberation can go the extra mile, it does. It delivers on all fronts, from a thoroughly engrossing single-player campaign to an addictive multiplayer component. Liberation also shames most other PSP offerings through its presentation.

90

PSW Magazine UK

It's original, atmospheric and challenging, and sets things up nicely for the stunning PS3 game. Let the hype begin again.

90

AceGamez

Visually Liberation is outstanding, keeping the rustic color palette and de-saturated look of the original perfectly while adding even more environmental details.

100

AceGamez

It's graphically stunning, the sound effects and music immerse you into a tense and exciting atmosphere of total chaos, a strong story compels you through a long single player campaign full of variety and challenge against tough enemies and the fully online multiplayer mode can be played split screen with a bunch of bots for those without a network adapter.

95

PSM Magazine

Killzone was worth the wait, and matches the hype. It hits the mark in so many ways, it's baffling; they promised us we'd experience fugture war, and we have...and come away shaking. [Holiday 2004, p.70]

92

Gaming Illustrated

Offers up some of the best graphics on the PS2 to date, and certainly is the most entertaining FPS game we've played on the console ever.

91

Next Level Gaming

OK, let me put it plain and simple to you. Killzone is the best Playstation 2 FPS to date. Forget about all those other wannabe shooters and watered down Xbox-to-Playstation 2 ports, this game is it.

90

Official Playstation 2 Magazine UK

Visually amazing FPS that'll rock your game world every time. [Jan 2007, p.106]

89

XGP Gaming

The environments are for the most part, spectacular. War debris is everywhere, worn out tanks lay forgotten amongst the destroyed buildings. All of it does relate for one hell of a war feel and setting.

88

Games Radar UK (Pre-2006)

A gorgeous, big, weighty, important event-game that makes good on most of its grandiose promises. Easily in the top two first-person shooters for PS2 alongside "TimeSplitters 2." [PSM2]

85

Stuff

Even though it offers the best online play Sony has to offer, it still comes up a few frags shy of toppling Master Chief, mostly because our poor PS2 seemed to be struggling to run the game.

84

TotalGames.net

While the frame rate occasionally dips and pop-up hasn't been totally eradicated Killzone looks stunning. However, Killzone's total focus on fire fights means that anyone that doesn't relish the thought of scrapping for every inch of territory, yearning for puzzles, switches, vehicles to pilot or woe-betide, aliens, should look elsewhere.

Stop hating, especially if you've never even played either game.

@vizunary

your list is not complete

79
GamingTrend
While Killzone: Liberation isn’t mindblowing and has some flaws, it's a good action game for a game system on the go.
Read Full Review
78
Games Master UK
Tries too hard to be PSP's killer app, but is just too inhibited to ever really blow you away. [Dec 2006, p.76]
75
Official U.S. Playstation Magazine
Having a real pal alongside to shoot the crap out of the Helghast soldiers takes a bite out of their uncanny accuracy. [Dec. 2006, p.128]
75
Detroit Free Press
The biggest flaw? The single-player game is too short. And there's no online mode. But if you can find a friend with the game, the multiplayer maps make for explosive fun.
Read Full Review
75
GamePro
However, Liberation is a worthy new chapter in the Killzone series and does more right than it does wrong. [Dec. 2006, p.122]
Read Full Review
73
Game Informer
The action in Liberation is good, and at times intense, but it still seems to lack that visceral experience I like to have with my action games, first person or otherwise.
Read Full Review
70
Edge Magazine
A couple of murderous boss battles spike the difficulty level during the second half, but what occurs for the most part is a largely cyclical, if inspired and infectious routine. [Dec 2006, p.83]
70
Yahoo! Games
Killzone isn't able to fulfill its own potential in the end. More variety in the gameplay would make this the killer app it's ready to become.
Read Full Review
70
games(TM)
Killzone: Liberation has considerable depth that really manages to please. [Dec 2006, p.130]
70
EuroGamer
An intense, challenging and well-designed game, simple enough to come off extremely well on the PSP and strategically engaging enough to keep cerebral players involved.
Read Full Review
70
Pro-G
If it wasn't so mercilessly difficult then Killzone: Liberation would easily give current PSP benchmark Syphon Filter: Dark Mirror a run for its money.
Read Full Review
70
Game Almighty
Liberation allows you to play co-op with another friend, heading out together on the same boring missions that comprise the campaign.
Read Full Review
67
Gaming Age
The lack of proper online play is a downer, and in spite of the difficulty, the game could have been a bit longer "out of the box". But overall, the game is an intense shooter with a gritty, cohesive sense of style and direction, and I can't see many fans of the genre being disappointed with it.
Read Full Review
65
Play Magazine
Any game can be an emotional experience if it has a little soul. And to put it bluntly, Killzone: Liberation is just soulless. [Oct. 2006, p.66]
60
PALGN
Conceptually solid, interesting and potentially enjoyable, but let down by poor execution and a sense of disconnection.
Read Full Review
58
Game Revolution
A fun but frustrating action romp with some good unlockable content and a really short single player campaign.
Read Full Review
57
Electronic Gaming Monthly
Running from cover to cover, you'll need to master the art of popping out at just the right time to blow away the enemy. Unfortunately, Liberation seems unsure what to do with it, falling into a repeating loop of key hunts, escort missions, and increasingly impossible battles. Bummer. [Dec. 2006, p.156]
50
Pocket Gamer UK
Killzone is precisely average. It's mildly entertaining, sure, but also disappointingly flawed.
Read Full Review
50
1UP
Instead of creating a wide variety of situations, the dev team relied on key-card hunts, escort missions, and (surprisingly pointless) vehicle-piloting sections ad nauseam.
Read Full Review
50
NTSC-uk
Ends up feeling distinctly average in terms of design and implementation.
Read Full Review
50
Gamestyle
Despite the annoying difficulty, the most frustrating aspect is that you fully appreciate the potential for a decent Killzone game.
Read Full Review
40
G4 TV
Gameplay as a whole is woefully unbalanced, leading to death after death for no good reason. Each time, you will question your desire to persevere; it's a losing battle.

A 40????? That does not seem impressing to me at all. But I haven't played the game so I can't rate it myself. It was just that you put only favourable reviews there.

 The scaling part doesn't bother me so much, but the assigning a score part does and I would really like to know which ones were assigned a score based on general text impressions.

 As for Killzone, I've never understood why people got so worked up over it.  It's an over all meh franchise with the PS2 game being shitty and the PSP gaming being not bad but not good as well.  As someone else said, what is this game going to bring to the PS3 that other games already haven't?