Forums - Gaming Discussion - Game Informer 300: Readers' Poll 300 Games of All Time

I really liked what I saw here....lot of good games scored high on the lists. Overall, one of the better lists I have seen of this magnitude.

It'd be nice to know how many people actually took part in the poll, but hey...I thought it'd be cool to share this here since this site too is getting ready for the 2020 Greatest Games of All Time.

https://www.gameinformer.com/b/features/archive/2018/03/19/readers-choice-top-300-games-of-all-time.aspx



Around the Network

Shadow of the Colossus is at #17, that's good!

However I guess the reader base are no fans of racing (or sports). The first mairo kart (8) is at #169, while the only other racing game is Gran Turismo at #220. Is that all GTs together or the first one?? Grim Fandango is in there, Doom and even Zork 1, a text adventure from 1980. Yet the top 10 is mostly recent games, odd mix of readers.



Gave it a passing glance, and it's a very respectable list!

Fortnite is 168. Nevermind. Burn it. Burn this list like the trash it is!!!!



The sentence below is false. 
The sentence above is true. 

 

For real though, the list is pretty good. Especially when you look at the top 50.



The sentence below is false. 
The sentence above is true. 

 

Top 10 needs a good reshuffle however the rest seems okay.
Again opinions.

EDIT: Never mind, i take that back. Half Life 2 #40 and Half Life 1 #91.. Gameinformer has poor taste.



Around the Network

The list definitely skews towards more recent games, which I think entails the respondents skewed relatively young. Recency bias may come into effect as well. We don't see a 16-bit game until Chrono Trigger at #11, there's not an NES game until Super Mario Bros. 3 at #37. In total, I counted only three NES games in the Top 100, and only five SNES games. The highest-ranked Genesis game was Sonic 3 at #159. The only games from the Golden Age of Arcades that I saw were Galaga and Donkey Kong (no Pac-Man!) and they were close to the bottom. So many classics are way down the list. I mean, how the hell else does BioShock Infinite and Destiny end up ranking higher than, Street Fighter II, Mortal Kombat II, Mega Man 2, Super Mario Bros., or Doom?

I'd really like to know what the age demographics of this poll were and their platforms owned. If I had to venture a guess, there weren't a ton of grizzled old Gen X vets like me that have been playing since the 80s.



Ocarina of Time and Final Fantasy VII have once again stood the test of time I see. I doubt those other games at the top would still be in the top 5 of such a list after 21 years, regardless of how good or not they may be.



Yeah, a somewhat strong recency bias and an even stronger western bias. I see some titles that are more old-school like Zork I, Sid Meier's Pirates, Baldur's Gate and Diablo, but overall important titles are missing, Heroes of Might and Magic III is the only entry in the HoMM series, and the base Might & Magic series is missing completely. Similarly no Ultima, no Monkey Island, no Maniac Mansion, no no Space/Kings Quest, no Indiana Jones. Grim Fandango is really the only LucasArts adventure? Dragon Quest VIII is the only Dragon Quest on the list. Monster Hunter World is the only MonHun title. No Warrior's entry. I'm not too much into arcade, but it seems lackluster in that regard too. Very restricting list.

Last edited by Mnementh - on 08 January 2020

3DS-FC: 4511-1768-7903 (Mii-Name: Mnementh), Nintendo-Network-ID: Mnementh, Switch: SW-7706-3819-9381 (Mnementh)

my greatest games: 2017, 2018, 2019

Predictions: Switch / Switch vs. XB1 in the US / Three Houses first quarter

There's a lot of weird things with this list, but I think one of the weirdest is that Red Dead Redemption is as high as #8 but Red Dead Redemption 2 isn't in the top 300 at all.



I am currently sigless.

Yeah, I gotta agree. There's a big recency bias here.
Last of Us is a great game.. but there is absolutely no way in hell I would ever rank it above Final Fantasy VII or Ocarina of Time.



Pancho A. Ovies

Nintendo Switch in Japan (Famitsu): 2018 vs. 2019
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=238945&page=2

PlayStation 4/Xbox One/Nintendo Switch: 2018 vs. 2019
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=239387