Oh, I see people are already working hard to poison the well if Death Stranding wins by blaming it on Keighley being biased. Of course, that's pretty silly, since there are like 50 people voting, but that's what makes such arguments fun to watch.
Regardless, it's a relatively down year, as to be expected this late in the generation. None of those games would win most years. Some years, none of those games would likely finish above third, and a couple of them probably wouldn't get nominated. Not that it really matters, of course, as people make a far bigger deal out of this than it deserves.