Forums - Movies Discussion - Do you think Black Panther is better than Thor 3?

Black Panther has pounced out Thor 3 for the box office lead and is taking names still. 

I have heard many say it is better than Thor 3 at my work. Do you believe this to be true?

Do you have reasons?



    The NINTENDO PACT 2015[2016  Vgchartz Wii U Achievement League! - Sign up now!                      My T.E.C.H'aracter

Around the Network

I enjoyed Black Panther more than I enjoyed Thor: Ragnarok. Overall the aesthetics of Thor were a turn off to me. I didn't care for the way they handled Sakaar and I feel like the soundtrack was far too forced.



It’s a better movie than Thor 3. But Thor 3 has more re-watchability to me



Thor 3, to me was boring and very textbook in terms of its action and story. Visually it was fun, but thats about it. The mix of childish and dry humour was a no for me.

Black Panther, with its poor cgi and lack of action (very noticeable) on 2nd viewings will age quite badly. Still a good movie though. Great writing and characters especially the ladies. In fact, Tessa was the highlight for Thor for me.



Yes, Thor 3 was good but it felt like they just made a Guardians of the Galaxy movie without the Guardians. Black Panther was more inline with Captain America 2, and I liked the dynamic that Wakanda faced with foreign aid and and community by race. Rather than point fingers in relation to the real world, Wakanda as a country has a very unique position as an advanced African society.



Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda!!!!


Around the Network
foodfather said:

Black Panther, with its poor cgi and lack of action (very noticeable) on 2nd viewings will age quite badly. Still a good movie though. Great writing and characters especially the ladies. In fact, Tessa was the highlight for Thor for me.

See, Tessa I felt was the weakest actor in that movie. But I do agree on BP cgi. Hopefully with the sequel they wont make that mistake again, knowing how much money this one made.



Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda!!!!


Easily.Thor 3, while a good movie, was too comedy heavy for a movie that wanted and needed to be taken more seriously.Personally I think that they made Thor too much of a jester.Black Phanter on the other hand is much more balanced.



My (locked) thread about how difficulty should be a decision for the developers, not the gamers.

https://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=241866&page=1

Thor was more funny...but Black Panther had Vegeta! (Yea he's a big fan)



Honestly, I feel like both of these movies offered the best villains thus far and the Marvel cinematic universe. Thor: Ragnarok was by far my favorite Thor movie, but I feel some of the comedy cheapened the impact of the more dramatic scenes. Black Panther did a great job, had some of the strongest women I have seen in a Marvel movie and just outright stole the show as far as origin stories go.



Not even close for me. Black Panther was a competent hero's journey with some good characterization and back story fleshing out conflict and world. Thor Ragnarok was painful to watch, just a train wreck of tone and attempts at humor. I laughed more during Black Panther because they felt like people rather than children's cartoon characters.