Okay I know, its earlyand I never thought it was possible but after seeing the debut of halo 5 in the uk , i realized i think the halo behemoth isn't as popular as it was , and ND is extremely popular this gen, so could uncharted 4 first week beat halo 5s ??

note halo 3 on xbox 360 released on a similar install base as halo 5 on xbox one , and still sold 3.3m first week ( sold like 370k first week in the usa )

i think halo 5 will sell 1.9 to 2.1m first week

uncharted 4 2.4m to 2.6m

lifetime i'm pretty sure uncharted will win due to difference in install base so its strictly first week sales

I think Uncharted 4 is going to stomp Halo 5 both quality and saleswise.

I always said it would outsell it day 1 and lifetime, but it's definitely going to outdo it review wise also.

Based on sales? Pretty sure Uncharted has no chance.

Halo is a bigger franchise and released in the run up to the holidays. Uncharted is a big but not has big and is releasing in a quieter part of the year. Halo sales should be more front ended while Uncharted won't be as front ended.

Sales wise there is no doubt UC4 will be the biggest hit on PS4.

Reviews may touch upon the fact it doesn't look like its doing anything drastically different from previous games. People act like its a sandbox game or something, but its still heavily scripted and linear roller coaster ride. Could still score above 90 on metacritic, but who knows.

Melodramatic and unsatisfying story, being too linear, beeing, not being inovative etc could all bring the score down, which I think will be the case with UC4. 

uncharted 4 will be better, aint hard with a crap story halo 5 have and with a 4h story mode in normal mode...

Uncharted 4 will sell more than Halo 5.

Its closer to 7 hours,  bit I see your one of these...

Uncharted 4's going to need an absolute fuck ton of bundling to outsell Halo 5's first week or lifetime sales, given the series past I guess that's possible. I'd still put my money on Halo 5.

I don't think Uncharted is a very popular series, looking at Youtube views, Google Trends and FB fan pages, it's just not that big really.

Halo 5 will more than double Uncharted 4's first week sales.