By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics Discussion - Is Socialism Anti-American?

 

Is it?

Yes 85 28.72%
 
NO 183 61.82%
 
Opinion below 8 2.70%
 
other 13 4.39%
 
Total:289

Given that some place in the US live like weird religious sects... its not surprising. You can fool the dumbest people with just about anything.



Around the Network
Mr Khan said:
Marks said:
prayformojo said:
Marks said:
prayformojo said:
No, but the "patriots" er...elite capitalistic pigs who believe in hoarding 90% of the resources for themselves while bleeding,starving and enslaving the poor will tell you otherwise.

 

You sound like the type of guy that supports high business taxes, and union rights...then wonders why all the factories are moving to China. 

I don't give two shits about business moving to China. You think you'd have concluded as much considering my views on our current system.

Our country is one built on the old idea that it's "every man for himself." I do not believe that way. I believe we are all in this together as a human race. We should all take care of one another and those who feel otherwise, should be made to treat others with such respect. If our goal is to better the human experience, then we can not keep going on with this insane notion of "every man for himself." We are going to have to make laws to protect the unfit from the fit if the fit continue to abuse the unfit. We are going to have to ensure that hoarders of resources can not hoard them anymore, and provide for those who can not provide for themselves.

Anything less is inhumane imo. We, as people, should all take care of one another. It's the only humane choice.


Well you sound like a good, genuine guy. But come on it's always been every man for himself and always will be. From back in caveman times all the way to today. 

Hell I bet the first caveman that discovered fire fucking sold burning embers to his cavemen buddies for their fish and raw meat or whatever the hell cavemen could possibly barter with. It's engrained in our DNA. 

As great as us all joining hands on communal farms and living together in harmony sounds, I don't think that could ever happen. 

If we want to get that primeval, humans, like apes, are tribal creatures, and the man (or woman, just as likely back then) who discovered fire would have freely shared it with the members of their "in-group." Tribal socialism is probably closest to the natural order of things if we want to make that argument, where there is property and ownership, but it falls to large family-clans who live in anarchic states vis-a-vis one another, but who organize things for the good of the group within. Tribal socialism is likely what we would revert to in some kind of post-apocalyptic setup, because without an infrastructure to support organized trade, individualism cannot function on the most basic level (unless you're the mountain man type who can secure all but a few of the necessities on your own, but even then, your survival is easier if you join a group where people work for a common purpose).

Individualism, as we know it, evolved away from that very slowly, not taking a recognizable form until the 1700s.

Well yeah of course the caveman with the fire would share it with his family and his main homies, but I'm betting he traded it to competing tribes for whatever they had that he didn't. i.e. Early capitalism and back then there weren't ridiculous arbitrary regulations. 



It depends on what you define as American. Do you define American as not being socialist? In this case, socialism is anti-American. Or would you say that, objectively, America cannot be socialist? If you maintain this definition of America, then socialism is anti-American. Or do you define socialism as something that is anti-American? In this case, socialism is anti-American.



spurgeonryan said:
NolSinkler said:
It depends on what you define as American. Do you define American as not being socialist? In this case, socialism is anti-American. Or would you say that, objectively, America cannot be socialist? If you maintain this definition of America, then socialism is anti-American. Or do you define socialism as something that is anti-American? In this case, socialism is anti-American.


On a big E3 day?

 

Umm..I think Americans can and should be allowed to do whatever they want, be what ever they want. Saying that, Socialism and Communism are usually both things frowned upon in America. It is just not illegal anymore. Was it ever illegal? Just highly frowned upon. No, I refuse to look at some history website. I am pretty sure it was illegal to be communist.

But this is not about communism. This is about America. We do not like Communism. Socialism makes many upset. But seems we are going that way. I heard the other day that Obama is trying to bring minumum wage up to the Teens? Crazy!


Bold:  The Capitalist Motto



NNID: garretslarrity

Steam: garretslarrity

am i the only one who thinks dems and reps goverment leaders  are both super annoying and are ruining our country
no just me ok



Bets:

(Won)Bet with TechoHobbit: He(Techno) says 10 million by January 1,2014 I say 9 million by then. Winner gets 2 weeks of sig control.

(Lost)Bet with kinisking: I say Ps4 will win April NPD while he says Xbox One will win it; winner gets 1 week of avatar control.

Raichu's First Series:

First RPG?

First Fighter?

First Racer?

First Shooter?

First MMO?

First Horror?

Official Ni No Kuni Fanboy:

Familiars Captured:37

Game Beaten: 2 times almost

Times I got teary during some scenes: 3

Around the Network
DevilRising said:
What an incredibly dumb question to ask. And I'm sorry, the people answering "yes" are also dumb. Saying that any political philosophy short of facism is "unamerican" or "anti-american", goes against the very point and foundation of this country. Where people could be FREE to believe and practice whatever they wished. That didn't just mean religion, it also meant social and political beliefs.

I am a "Democratic Socialist", and I'm proud of that. I don't make a big deal of it, but I'm also not ashamed of it, and why should I be? To me, "socialism" means caring more about the overall good of the people, than the good of the government or big business. To me, "socialism" merely means caring about more than just yourself or your immediate circle. And I think quite a LOT of Americans have a very skewed and incorrect view of what socialism as a philosophy actually is. It has nothing to do with politics. It is a set of socio-economic ideals and values.

So stating that "socialism is anti-American", is outright stupidity. I'm sorry if that upsets some people, but it's the truth. People in America are allowed to believe and think however the fuck they want, and the only thing that would be TRULY "anti-American", would be someone actively trying to deny people that right.


Just splitting the hair here, but isnt socialism an economical/sociological term, rather then political? I mean you can have a socialist economy even if you have democracy orcommunism. It was never trully clear for me, and I think its understandable,m mainly because there is probably no concrete definition and several schools of toughts about it.

And I think that is the core issue here. Socialism is not well defined and 99% of people have no idea what it means. They use it like a buzzword, ever since the bolshevik revolution and it managed to receive an extremely negative stigma.

But then you look at many northern europen countries where the quality of life is arguably the best in the world, and found out that most of them have a naturaly evolved socialist economy. Not in the purest form, mind you, but then there are rarely any politcal or economic phenomenas that are on-par with their definition.



Vote the Mayor for Mayor!

Isn't the welfare of the people written down in the constitution? Socialism is an integrated part in every society, just as capitalism is. So no, believing in welfare for the people is not anti-American.



Just reading Jack London's 'Iron heel'. Fantastic reading. Try it, its about American view on socialism and capitalism of a century ago, but a lot of things seems fresh and modern.



The short answer is "no."
Believe it or not, things in America aren't quite what they seem to be. The people living here in the USA don't really know much about their own country or the classification of their own beliefs. Many are just raised to demonize certain beliefs while praising another, not really knowing what each entails. The USA contains many kinds of people, and to call whichever one the "American" way is, in fact, not how America became what most people like about it.



If it wasnt for socialist ideals we wouldn't have public services, from public postal service to education and more. The socialist pillar is kind of whats holding this country together to be quite honest. The banks and businesses during the economic downfall depended on the tax dollar of the American consumer. Essentially we all had stock in them for that short period of time to keep them running. Very socialist indeed. That baillout was quite socialist, but it saved our economy from collapsing on its head.