UPDATE ! (REVIEWS ARE IN, MASTERPIECE STATUS CONFIRMED):

Reviews {Included in Meta as of 6th June 18PM GMT+2}:
28 Perfect Scores out of 57 reviews

________________________________

Eurogamer Sweden: 10/10
Joystiq: 10/10
PushSquare: 10/10
TheSixthAxis: 10/10
Telegraph: 10/10
PS Lifestyle: 10/10
Guardian: 10/10
Gameblog(fr): 10/10
Eurogamer Spain: 10/10
SpazioGames: 10/10
GameReactor Sweden: 10/10
GamesRadar: 10/10
CheatCodeCentral: 10/10
OPM UK: 10/10
VideoGamer: 10/10
Edge: 10/10
Eurogamer EU: 10/10
IGN: 10/10
Destructoid: 10/10
Giant Bomb: 10/10
The Digital Fix: 10/10
Machinima: 10/10
Digital Spy: 10/10
Everyeye.it: 10/10
Eurogamer Portugal: 10/10
Post Arcade: 10/10
Eurogamer Italy: 10/10
Games.cz: 10/10
NZGamer: 9.8/10
PSX Extreme: 9.8/10
Vandal Online: 9.8/10
3DJuegos: 9.7/10
Meristation: 9.7/10
Multiplayer.it: 9.7/10
Canadian Online Gamers: 9.7/10
InsideGamer.nl: 9.5/10
Gamer.nl: 9.5/10
GamingTrend: 9.5/10
PSX-sense.nl: 9.5/10
LaPS3: 9.5/10
JeuxActu: 9.5/10
EGM: 9.5/10
GameInformer: 9.5/10
PS Universe: 9.5/10


XGN: 9/10
The Escapist: 9/10
Metro GameCentral: 9/10
IGN Italy: 9/10
The Globe and Mail: 9/10
Games(TM): 9/10
GamesBeat: 9/10
GameReactor Denmark: 9/10


NowGamer: 8.5/10
Gamespot: 8/10
Toronto Sun: 8/10
Polygon: 7.5/10
________________________________

Reviews that are not included in meta (might be added later or not, I have no idea):
47 Perfect Scores out of 49 reviews

________________________________

JVM: 20/20
Gameblog: 5/5
CVG: 10/10
Ibtimes: 10/10
Gamingbolt 10/10
Speciogames 10/10
PS-Nation 10/10
Techdigest 5/5
TheMirror 5/5
AdamSessler 5/5
Godisageek 10/10
GameReactor Norway: 10/10
GameReactor Italia: 10/10
GameReactor Spain: 10/10
Rev3 - 5/5
Empire Online - 5/5
Examiner - 5/5
Mirror - 5/5
IGN Denmark - 10/10
Financial Post - 10/10
Playstadium - 10/10
Jeuxvideomagazine - 20/20
Eurogamer Denmark - 10/10
Nextgengamingblog - 10/10
Minhembio - 10/10
JAGS - 10/10
USA Today - 4/4
3newz - 5/5
Eurogamer France - 10/10
Eurogamer Czech Republic - 10/10
Tiscali.cz - 10/10
Dailymail - 5/5
nbcnews - 10/10
The Slanted - 10/10
SFX - 5/5
Gamesector - 10/10
AnaitGames - 10/10
Videogame.it - 5/5
Accelerated-ideas - 5/5
Stuff.tv - 5/5
PSmania - 10/10
HREJ - 10/10
Boothammer - 10/10
JeuxVideo.fr - 10/10
BagoGames - 5/5
JV.Com: 19/20
Gamekult: 9+ <- (Site has never given a 10, very few game gets a 9)
________________________________
Total perfect scores out of total reviews:
75 Perfect out of 109 Total

Everyone who has played the demo is all praise. So I also expect a high score. I think that it'll be between 90-92.

0.1/10

I won't get hyped!

87-91 metascore.

With the way this generation has been going, I wouldn't be surprised to see the game score below 90 on Metacritic, even if it "deserves" more. So 88-92 is my prediction.

In addition, I'll hopefully be picking it up Day 1, it's a game which has intrigued me pretty much from the get-go and I can't wait to see if it lives up to the hype!

They said amazing things about Aliens Colonial Marines as well. I'm certainly not suggesting the same will happen here, but it's very difficult to get a feel for a game from a short demo.

PUTTIN DOWN TEH TAGZ!!!

Anything over 85 should be good. Heck make it 80 as we are at the end of gen. Obviously i am being conservative with those numbers. I really stopped caring for Metacritic all that much now. You got people who throw 100's and than those who just give low review scores to get hits.

All the best Naughty Dog

90-95 and actually I hope for more. If it is really good and also sells very well then we'll probably see more original games as well as new franchises.

I've only heard one complain of this game thus far, and that was the AI of one of the companions (Not the girl). The rest is impeccable, I think.