By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - (Update) Horrible review, The reviewer has joined & insulting me, is this right?

 

If you played the game, do you think this review was good?

YES 89 52.66%
 
NO 79 46.75%
 
Total:168
Jay520 said:
easyrider said:
JoeTheBro said:
Sounds good to me. He did fine.


Ok a 5/10 for things he had control over. LOL what? You just don't like the game. Whats with sony fans and negative atitudes all the time. Just my opinion but it seems nothing is good enough and everything has to be free or most sony fans don't like it, Even when sony for doing so is losing millions if not billions. I think in the end the sony gamers will be the demise of PS.  I guess I went on a rant but for you not to see a problem is kinda of wierd. Unless your the reviewer or you don't like the game in the first place.


hmmm...looks like you have the most negative attitude in this thread.


You could be right but so could I. You bolded a question? questions are questions, sorry you thought it was a negative question. Answer the question. It was a random thought. There are negative people on both sides but I see a lot of posts from sony fans saying stuff about never wanting to pay. Maybe it's a vgchartz trend. I don't mind supporting a company if the service is great.  Live has great service, you do get free games and the company can keep making money. Sony has lost a butt load off the free service. They are trying to start going towards a pay service because they can't afford it but they know most of their fans are not that loyal to understand the costs. Do a thread about how many people would pay for psn and I bet you get more than half saying they wouldn't buy the console anymore. I did derail the thread and yes I stereo typed but it was more of a question than anything.



Around the Network
ganoncrotch said:
easyrider said:

The review was of Dead Space 3. by Gordon Bryant

The reasons for this review and it's low score are horribly. As stated the reviewer says ammo is to plentyful, yet doesn't change the difficulty level that changes that exact problem. I think this review should be taken down and a real reviewer should do it over. clearly his review focus's on it being to easy. Well thats why they have things called difficulty levels and it takes 5 seconds to change the setting.  Also he doesn't like the plot because a religion took over and are making horrible decisions. He says that would have never happened. Take a look at history, not to hard to see that it has happened many times. He also complains about wait times in the game. Fine but  as someone already mentioned, he sounds like he is going more on a rant, then a professional review. Sorry but this review was bad at best. He should not be allowed to review anymore games because he is not ready for his job.

Everyone on the page that has posted disagree's with his review, accept him.

http://www.gamrreview.com/review/89780/dead-space-3-ps3/

Please add anything you think I missed about this bad review.

keep in mind that Gamrreview while shown in the latest stories column on the front page here, isn't in fact the same website as VGchartz, for the Articles just by the writers of this site you wanna scroll down to the middle under the hardware sales for the week where it says Latest Articles, that is 100% vgchartz stuff.

As for gammmmrrrrrrrrrrrrrreview stuff, it's junk, most of the reviews put up there fetch 300-500 views unless they are absolutely off the wall wrong on scores when the draw a fraction more interest, in the long term tho it's not like the reviews there have any weight on anywhere other than that site, they are not even allowed by metacritic as actual critical reviews, they are indeed just rants for the few hundrew people who click the site. Kinda like Ben Zero Punctuation guy... but... yeah without the funny.

Thats nice to know. I thought it was a part of metacritic. Either way it just sounded way off to me that he made his own problems and than blames the game. Thats what really got me going. I'm like, What?lOL



Seems overwhelmingly that people agree with me. Let it be noted that the reviewer came in here and voted for himself. So one of those votes is from him. LOL He probably had others come in here and vote for him. LOL



easyrider said:


You could be right but so could I. You bolded a question? questions are questions, sorry you thought it was a negative question. Answer the question. It was a random thought. There are negative people on both sides but I see a lot of posts from sony fans saying stuff about never wanting to pay. Maybe it's a vgchartz trend. I don't mind supporting a company if the service is great.  Live has great service, you do get free games and the company can keep making money. Sony has lost a butt load off the free service. They are trying to start going towards a pay service because they can't afford it but they know most of their fans are not that loyal to understand the costs. Do a thread about how many people would pay for psn and I beat you get more than half saying they wouldn't buy the console anymore. I did derail the thread and yes I stereo typed but it was more of a question than anything.


LOLWUT?

Dude, calm down. This has nothing to do with PSN being free or Dead Space 3 not being free. What are you talking about? 



Jay520 said:
easyrider said:


You could be right but so could I. You bolded a question? questions are questions, sorry you thought it was a negative question. Answer the question. It was a random thought. There are negative people on both sides but I see a lot of posts from sony fans saying stuff about never wanting to pay. Maybe it's a vgchartz trend. I don't mind supporting a company if the service is great.  Live has great service, you do get free games and the company can keep making money. Sony has lost a butt load off the free service. They are trying to start going towards a pay service because they can't afford it but they know most of their fans are not that loyal to understand the costs. Do a thread about how many people would pay for psn and I beat you get more than half saying they wouldn't buy the console anymore. I did derail the thread and yes I stereo typed but it was more of a question than anything.


LOLWUT?

Dude, calm down. This has nothing to do with PSN being free or Dead Space 3 not being free. What are you talking about? 


I'm not mad at all.

Not sure why you think I am.



Around the Network
easyrider said:

I'm not mad at all.

Not sure why you think I am.


I figured your off topic rant could only be caused by madness.



Maybe he simply didn't think the game was very good overall? A 5 is smack dab in the average territory, its just that we have gotten used to all games landing in the 80-99 category so we assume that anything below 80-75 is complete shit.
This is is not the case, this would be a 3/4 on the dice, an okay score.



Mummelmann said:
Maybe he simply didn't think the game was very good overall? A 5 is smack dab in the average territory, its just that we have gotten used to all games landing in the 80-99 category so we assume that anything below 80-75 is complete shit.
This is is not the case, this would be a 3/4 on the dice, an okay score.


not really the case there has been a large number of games coming out with lower scores than people expected, Halo4, CoD declassified, Sony Playstation All-Stars and Aliens C marines come to mind. From what I make out from this reviewer defending his review on here, he took score off the game because it was such a big budget title he expected more for his money.... don't know which country he lives in where you pay by the budget of the game, but still he did give it a worse score because it's budget should have made for a better score, This has nothing to do with the game or the gameplay as you sit in your room and enjoy it as such it's pointless to add to a review.

 

Edit - Should point out, I didn't read the review on the site as it is more than clearly not a good review site, and as such I do not feel the need to give them advertising hits.



Why not check me out on youtube and help me on the way to 2k subs over at www.youtube.com/stormcloudlive

Jay520 said:
easyrider said:

I'm not mad at all.

Not sure why you think I am.


I figured your off topic rant could only be caused by madness.


Now your on to something. LOL



While i belive Dead Space 3 is a mediocre game and certainly isn't in the same league as Dead Space 1 or 2, i still agree with the OP that the review wasn't good or respresentative at all.