Forums - Sony Discussion - Uncharted 3; GOTY hands down!

Well it certainly has a shot at having the most GOTY awards there are far too many amazing looking games that are also very strong contenders.

Games like Skyrim, Dark Souls, Battlefield 3, MW3, Halo: CEA, Rage, Gears 3, Skyward Sword, Portal 2 and Arkham City are all strong contenders as well.

Around the Network

I Vote for the 2nd half of this year as my GOTY!!! :D

Ricoswuave38 said:
I Vote for the 2nd half of this year as my GOTY!!! :D

good point! so many great games coming out!! lol

Jay520 said:
sales2099 said:
I dont know. The shooting mechanics are sloppier then Gears 3, nor its multiplayer as diverse and addictive. And with Karenn Traviss writing the Gears story, Uncharted 3 better have a great story.

Have you played the beta? The shooting was smooth & responsive. I think you have a problem with the recoil from the guns. Although recoil is expected. UC3 is meant to be more realistic than Gears. It's trying to be different. That doesn't mean it's necessarilly inferior. In fact, it could be seen as superior depending on what to you're looking for: Recoil vs no recoil.

OT: Dark Souls or Zelda will most likely be GOTY for me. UC3 will be next though, atlhough Gears 3 & Arkham City could surpass UC3 if they're good enough.

youre giving a legitamite response to someone who came in here never expecting a legitamite discussion.

you can see by his post history, that every thing he writes about sony, isnt exactly... lets say balanced.


you could probably tell, the moment he said Uncharted doesnt have as diverse of multiplayer. i cant think of another game that incorporates as much gameplay mechanics into a game than Uncharted

If Dark Souls successfully improves on what made Demon's Souls so great, then I wouldn't be surprised if it becomes one of the major contenders for GotY. Demon's Souls was a dark horse back in 2009, winning GotY over Uncharted 2 on GameSpot, if I recall correctly.

Around the Network

it will be hard for uncharted 3 to claim as many GOTY as uncharted 2, it's going against some heavy competition:
Gears of war 3
LittleBigPlanet 2
Zelda Skyward Sword
Battlefield 3
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3
Batman: Arkham City
Dead Space 2(this ones a maybe)
Deus Ex; Human Revolution

are all saying hi to uncharted 3

Edit: Forgot Daek Souls

EGG_OF_D00m said:
i agree when it comes down to it.. uncharted 3 will be amazing

1. it's the best graphics on consoles yet
2. it's story is going to be amazing
3. amazing voice acting
4. revamped multiplayer
5. great replay value

this is all the quality's you need to win goty and all of that describes uncharted 3

Time Machine or Crystal Ball?

A serious contender no doubt.


Gaming on: PS4 Pro, Switch, SNES Mini, Wii U, PC (i5-7400, GTX 1060)

skyrim has a shot but gears doesn't no offence but how can u win with a lower metacritic then little big planet 2 and portal 2 etc.. alot of site's thought it was lackluster

I don't expect U3 to suck me iin like Zelda or Batman likely will and I don't expect it to absorb as much of my time as Gears 3 has and probably will (I suspect I'll actually prefer Saints Row to U3!) Still, I believe Uncharted will do absolutely nothing wrong and will be one of the most polished games of this generation. That's good enough for me.

It may not be MY game of the year (but then again, it could surprise me) and I think it's got some serious competition from games that I don't even care about (Skyrim, Battlefield, Dark Souls) but I fully intend to have a great time with this game. The series has quite a pedigree.

Twitter: @d21lewis  --I'll add you if you add me!!