94% Meta - I would reckon so, past few meta's though I've got completely wrong!

Top 3 GOTY - Goes hand in hand with reviews ...

750k First week - 600k IMO

+ 3 mill lifetime - 2.5 mill

I guess I'm a tad more conservative with my predictions ...

I'm guessing metascore to be 87-93(/100), 200 000 - 500 000k sales first week, best story GOTY.

Alan Wake is already mentioned. ;)

When the reviews start to pile in for this game and it gets the 7's, 8's and maybe a a few 9's sprinkled in all of thse people proclaiming alan wake to be the 360 savior will perish into obscurity.

Legend, get him..........

Tell you what, I'm so sure it'll get a metacritic average of 90 or over (majority of review scores being in the 9 to 10 range) that I'm willing to make a sig bet on it.

Severance - you're really unbelievably funny. PS3 threads are so boring.

Im sure AW is a great game and will bring a lot of joy to those who buy it. Might even be a system seller (yes I've been thinking of.....)

Can't wait for this Game... May still seems so far away!!
MAY 1ST -MAYWEATHER VS MOSLEY hahaha
May 14th? was it ALAN WAKE

Whether it surpasses Uncharted 2 in terms of graphics or not it doesn't really matter, to fanboy boys it does, Especially those PS3 Fanboys because they hate to see a game on the 360 surpassing PS3 graphics because 360 fanboy might taunt them and say 360 is better overall as a hardware. Undoubtedly Uncharted 2 or GOW3 is the best looking game to date on consoles
But Alan Wake looking impressive indeed

Alan Wake!! Wake up Hahaha

The 360 doesnt need a savior. That would imply it needs saving. It has alot of great games. And while I agree that reviewers will be very hard on the gameplay. It will end up around the score of Heavy Rain. Of course I'm hoping for 90+ though.

I think it will have better reviews than HR since a lot of reviewers just did not like the gameplay, but Alan Wake should be more easy to like, and the 360 exclusives get better scores anyway.