I think you misunderstood me. Saying "It can't be that good!" =/= "It's a bad game." They know perfectly well it's a good game. They just deny it being an absolutely amazing groundbreaking game. That is until they finally get their hands on it. And I've always gotten a chuckle out of that.
If you can afford to build a PC you can afford a console. Sure, lots of 3rd party series really should be platform agnostic. But let's face it. Many games will be stuck to a single platform for various reasons. You don't see console gamers whining that Warhammer II isn't on their platform of choice. I guarantee you that any console gamer that wants to play Warhammer (or other PC-Only games), will either build a PC or somehow live with the fact that they can't play a few games.
People can have a lot of different and valid reasons for not purchasing multiple systems. And it can be difficult to know whether or not something is groudbreaking before you try it yourself. It may even take several hours to get there.
But I don't think we should dwell on this in Vivster's (otherwise) positive thread about the game. So let's try to focus on the purpose of the thread.