TLOU2 is losing steam. Why?

[pikashoe]

IcaroRibeiro said:

Ka-pi96 said:

And I like it when people acknowledge that things they may not mind might be problems for other people, rather than just pretending everything is perfect and calling any criticism others may have "nonexistent".

Calling anything you don't enjoy in the story a plot whole when everything about it makes absolutely sense is just finding a nonexistent problem to justify (in a objective light) your own taste   

Edit: Just for practical example

- You hating Joel death and finding this a lame game decision that killed your enjoyment and criticizing ND deceptive marketing about what Joel hole in this game would be like = Ok  

- You stating the scene doesn't make sense = Finding a nonexistent problem  

I think people can easily make the claim that Joel is acting out of character during that scene which can be a problem for some people. That along with some big plot conveniences can also be a problem for some people. Abby just randomly running into Joel within a few minutes of her introduction is pretty clunky.