CGI-Quality said:
Ya know, I honestly see both sides of this argument (though this site was not built on the basis of console wars ). For JWein, I see why he would feel a need to take action, given it was a brand new account and its only post is an example of mild trolling (we are harsher on newer accounts). On the other? I get why it would frustrate people to see what could be perceived as mild trolling via a meme receive such harsh punishment. Though you have no idea of the user will ever post here again, it is a fair assumption to make. So, let's tackle it another way. What makes the post accurate? Was it fair to take that shot at Halo? Why? Would such a post have caused any further issues in that thread had it been left as it was? I'm open to hearing your feedback (though in the future, PM the mod in question first). |
Seems pretty unreasonable to me to "both sides" this. There was clear and transparent intent with the "mild meme" to rile up the XBOX fanbase, and I'm willing to bet that would be better explained and understood from someone coming from the XBOX community.
Last edited by Moren - on 26 July 2020