So i went and double checked my controllers. Seems like the first player controller stayed at the dimmed, but when I add additional controllers the light was always bright. So i dimmed my 2nd, 3rd and 4th controller and then turned them off, and when I turned them back on they were back on the bright setting. Like it only remembers controller setting for player 1? Or am i the only one having this problem?
Are you setting each one to an account or just using a guest?