By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
PAOerfulone said:

I'm still upset that Super Mario Galaxy didn't win in 2007. No disrespect to Bioshock.

For me, those two games were very close contenders not only for top game of 2007, but for last gen as a whole. I probably have to give the edge to SMG because it was just pure fun from beginning to end (and Nintendo needs to give it, and the rest of the older 3D Mario games, the HD treatment), but BioShock was no slouch in the gameplay department, either, and its setting, narrative, art design, and so on made for an incredibly engrossing experience.