Also, this post gave me c... no I won't say it because of that thread the other day. But it made me quite disappointed.
I don't see what about it offends you so much. I've played both series in the past, and while I think Smash is a fun distraction, time killer type of game, I don't feel like it has the "meat", or depth if you prefer, to have lasting appeal for me personally. Smash is the kind of game that I'll rent, play around with for maybe a week, a few hours a day, and send it back to Gamefly when I get bored. RDR2 is the kind of game that I will buy, marathon it on release, then replay it several times over the years, just like I did with the first RDR, which is my #1 all-time favorite game. If you prefer Smash that is perfectly fine, but my opinion is just as valid.