I never minded it as a teen strapped for cash but I'd never buy used anymore. Totally digital for me,my disk drive becoming a real life RNG simulator with installing games was the best hardware failure that ever happened to me.
Also,I'd reckon Gamestop give the disks a good wipe and polish so its the box you only need worry with, buy yourself a disk folder and ditch the boxes if it bothers you to that degree but it's not like you're dumpster diving :).



 

China Numba wan!!