Shadow of the Colossus
PlayStation 2 / Team Ico / 2005
Guessed by Wright
Whoa. That's really the best way to describe this game. Shadow of the Colossus is just a "whoa" experience in every way. The awesome gameplay aside, there's very few games out there with more immersive atmospheres than this, with the empty, silent overworld and the occasional colossus battle here and there. Couple that with one of the best soundtracks ever made and an absolutely mindblowing hell of a story, this really shines as a brilliant masterpiece.