By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Yoshiya said:
HylianSwordsman said:

 But no, he makes 4 of them. He's got to drive the point home for when he fake claims Marth.

But I call it out, and of course Astro decides that for calling out stupidity he's going to suspect me (it's actually for ruining the counterclaim he was setting up, of course). 

I agree with almost everything you say here (not sure it's quite evidence enough to accuse him of being scum but it is definitely weird behaviour). I was just wondering about these two comments above;

1) Why do you assume that he has to fake claim? Are you still sticking with the idea that all the good characters are town and all the bad characters are bad? I thought you said in this very post that you'd reconsidered that line of thinking.

2) I assume you mean fake claim rather than counterclaim in this second one?


Also, considering we have little time left and I really want a straight answer out of Radish,

Vote: Radishhead


1. I'm not assuming he HAS to fake claim, I'm saying that he's building a fake claim in case he needs it. Yes, I agreed it was possible for neutral characters to be scum, but not clear heroes. Regardless, until it becomes clear that scum can be something other than villains, building a hero claim is a good idea. Furthermore, when I was his scum buddy in the Fire Emblem game, he acted this way as well. Finally, note that he's since stopped the Marth claims now that Astro made the "town-sounding characters could be scum" argument.

2. Ah yes, I meant fakeclaim. I said counterclaim because I was talking about him trying to make room for a counterclaim proof fake claim of a non-playable character. So it should have read "ruining the counterclaim proof fake claim he was setting up.