Locked: Super Mario Galaxy: as overrated as halo 3

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Super Mario Galaxy: as overrated as halo 3

well, i have seen sales and reviews, and i have come to the conclusion that SMG is as overrated-if not more- than halo 3.  


1. it brings nothing new to the diminishing genre.  the genre is getting worn out, sticking to the same formula sence 1985.  i don't get it, how can people say a game is awesome if its been abot the same thing for nearly 25 years?

2. after 22 years, there is still no online.  what the hell? i think this game would be 10x better if it had some form of online multiplay, wither co-op or vs.  

3. i am gonna but burned p and thrown away for this topic anyway, so i might as well say it.  this game really does appeal more to CHILDREN 12 and under.  i honestly can't picture a 15-28 year old playing mario.  not many other people can either, obviously meaning that not many people over 12 play it.

well, better raise my shield... 



xbox 360, ps2 are my consoles 

 end of generation predictions: wii 106 million Xbox 360 59 million PS3 57 million  


Around the Network

this will be fun

Have you beaten either game? Have you played either game even?

To Each Man, Responsibility

Don't post blatant flamebait for no other purpose.

This is why I love Nintendo!

Around the Network

What are you?

did you not see the gameplay video?


That game is awsome, also I would like to add that it reminds me ALOT of reatchet and clank its almost the same thing except for the stars and art direction.