By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - COMG! Japan PRE-ORDER Chartz Thread - Will Be Updated Daily!

jarrod said:
NYANKS said:
jarrod said:

PSP2's launching at the end of 2011, and if rumors are true it's around 360-level spec.  Why would Capcom put together a HD level MH less than year out from MHP3 launch?  

I'm pretty sure MH will come to both 3DS and PSP2, but no, it won't happen anywhere near launch for either system.  As for the incentives on doing MH for one system or the other exclusively, I think they'd probably sell similarly on either, but on 3DS Capcom would have lower development costs (lower spec, can reuse Wii/PSP assets) and likely far better western potential (3DS is a sure bet in the west, PSP2 far less so).

I'd say the Western potential is your best point.  Hard to argue. The only thing I could maybe say is that MH sales in Japan are much more overwhelming than in the West, so maybe it won't hold TOO much sway.....

As for the develeopment costs, why wouldn't they have done that already?  Why didn't they pick the DS if that's what they cared about?  And surely it would be easier to translate PSP assets to a future PSP than to a future DS.  Right now my guess is PSP exclusive, followed VERY closely by multiplat.  I just couldn't fathom how dumb a move only 3DS would be, considering how much they'd be losing in Japan.

I'd say western potential was likely the biggest reason MH3 came to Wii over PS3, and that had a lot to do with the sort of support Nintendo put behind the game.  We'll see what Sony thinks of MH in the west, if they'll put the same kind of push behind MHP3 or not outside Japan.

As for development costs, DS actually would've been more expensive than PSP precisely because of asset reuse.  They'd have had to do everything ground up from scratch, while on PSP they could simply reuse a heavy amount of PS2/Wii assets.

A 3DS only MH future wouldn't be a dumb move for Japan either, it'd simply drive the fanbase to a new system (a la FFVII).  MH essentially built PSP's Japanese market base, not the reverse... PSP needs MH far, far more than MH needs PSP... 

Maybe, but unlike what would happen here,  FF became much more popular after the switch.  That wouldn't happen here, as the only way to get more popular would be to usurp Pokemon as biggest game in Japan, which I don't think anyone sees happening.  A 3DS exclusive move would be dumb if they could multiplat it.  Simply switching would just be odd, seeing as they already sell unbelievable numbers.  Yeah who knows, maybe Nintendo saw their 3rd party situation as kind of problematic and offered un-Nintendo like support, meaning more like Sony. 



Around the Network

Updated: December 03, 2010 (Fri) 07:00

Rankings as of December 2, 2010 closed

  • [PSP]Shining Hearts - 282pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 idol ... love you more than once does not produce Limited Edition! Auction No BOX - 184Pt
  • [PS3]Gundam Musou three - 167pt
  • [PSP]The 3rd Birthday - 123Pt
  • [NDS]The Raven mage二No country - 103pt
  • [PSP]Phantasy Star 2 Infinity - 96pt
  • [PSP] Portable does not have my sister is so cute, "my" in love with his sister by ♪ Box - 95pt
  • [PS3]Final Fantasy XIII Verusasu - 75Pt
  • [NDS]Eleven 3 World Challenge! di auger - 63pt
  • [PSP]Valkyria three - 53pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 Idol and love you ... (Limited Edition) - 51Pt
  • [Wii]Donkey Returns - 45pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 Idol and love you ... (Limited Edition) - 43Pt
  • [PSP]Portable Another Century's Episode - 41Pt
  • [PS3]Disgaea 4 (Limited Edition) - 40pt
  • [PS3]Black Ops Call of Duty (Dubbed) - 35Pt
  • [PSP]Magical Index term (Limited Edition) - 33Pt
  • [PSP]Final Mix Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep - 32pt
  • [PS3]Assassin's Creed Brotherhood - 29pt
  • [PS3]Metal Gear Solid Rising - 22pt
  •  

    I cant provide all the increases, but DK rose 13 points today. Kinda respectable, but we're all still hoping for more!



    kopstudent89 said:

    Updated: December 03, 2010 (Fri) 07:00

    Rankings as of December 2, 2010 closed

  • [PSP]Shining Hearts - 282pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 idol ... love you more than once does not produce Limited Edition! Auction No BOX - 184Pt
  • [PS3]Gundam Musou three - 167pt
  • [PSP]The 3rd Birthday - 123Pt
  • [NDS]The Raven mage二No country - 103pt
  • [PSP]Phantasy Star 2 Infinity - 96pt
  • [PSP] Portable does not have my sister is so cute, "my" in love with his sister by ♪ Box - 95pt
  • [PS3]Final Fantasy XIII Verusasu - 75Pt
  • [NDS]Eleven 3 World Challenge! di auger - 63pt
  • [PSP]Valkyria three - 53pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 Idol and love you ... (Limited Edition) - 51Pt
  • [Wii]Donkey Returns - 45pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 Idol and love you ... (Limited Edition) - 43Pt
  • [PSP]Portable Another Century's Episode - 41Pt
  • [PS3]Disgaea 4 (Limited Edition) - 40pt
  • [PS3]Black Ops Call of Duty (Dubbed) - 35Pt
  • [PSP]Magical Index term (Limited Edition) - 33Pt
  • [PSP]Final Mix Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep - 32pt
  • [PS3]Assassin's Creed Brotherhood - 29pt
  • [PS3]Metal Gear Solid Rising - 22pt
  •  

    I cant provide all the increases, but DK rose 13 points today. Kinda respectable, but we're all still hoping for more!

    That's good, it still has a week right?  Nice.

    P.S.  The list looks much more.....balanced now lol.



    NYANKS said:
    kopstudent89 said:

    Updated: December 03, 2010 (Fri) 07:00

    Rankings as of December 2, 2010 closed

  • [PSP]Shining Hearts - 282pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 idol ... love you more than once does not produce Limited Edition! Auction No BOX - 184Pt
  • [PS3]Gundam Musou three - 167pt
  • [PSP]The 3rd Birthday - 123Pt
  • [NDS]The Raven mage二No country - 103pt
  • [PSP]Phantasy Star 2 Infinity - 96pt
  • [PSP] Portable does not have my sister is so cute, "my" in love with his sister by ♪ Box - 95pt
  • [PS3]Final Fantasy XIII Verusasu - 75Pt
  • [NDS]Eleven 3 World Challenge! di auger - 63pt
  • [PSP]Valkyria three - 53pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 Idol and love you ... (Limited Edition) - 51Pt
  • [Wii]Donkey Returns - 45pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 Idol and love you ... (Limited Edition) - 43Pt
  • [PSP]Portable Another Century's Episode - 41Pt
  • [PS3]Disgaea 4 (Limited Edition) - 40pt
  • [PS3]Black Ops Call of Duty (Dubbed) - 35Pt
  • [PSP]Magical Index term (Limited Edition) - 33Pt
  • [PSP]Final Mix Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep - 32pt
  • [PS3]Assassin's Creed Brotherhood - 29pt
  • [PS3]Metal Gear Solid Rising - 22pt
  •  

    I cant provide all the increases, but DK rose 13 points today. Kinda respectable, but we're all still hoping for more!

    That's good, it still has a week right?  Nice.

    P.S.  The list looks much more.....balanced now lol.

    I know what u mean :P 

    And no it aint that good. this is the BIG Nintendo title for the holidays, and it needs to step up. Plus i really really want this to sell lol



    Good, DK rose 13 points, but I know you can do more! Go DK!



    Above: still the best game of the year.

    Around the Network

    Nice jump on VC3 and still over month before release.



    PROUD MEMBER OF THE PSP RPG FAN CLUB

    Updated: Dec 04, 2010 (Sat) 10:00

    Rankings as of December 3, 2010 closed

  • [PSP]Shining Hearts - 289pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 idol ... love you more than once does not produce Limited Edition! Auction No BOX - 188Pt
  • [PS3]Gundam Musou three - 171pt
  • [PSP]The 3rd Birthday - 128Pt
  • [NDS]The Raven mage二No country - 107pt
  • [PSP]Phantasy Star 2 Infinity - 97pt
  • [PSP] Portable does not have my sister is so cute, "my" in love with his sister by ♪ Box - 96pt
  • [PS3]Final Fantasy XIII Verusasu - 75Pt
  • [NDS]Eleven 3 World Challenge! di auger - 68pt
  • [PSP]Valkyria three - 54pt
  • [Wii]Donkey Returns - 52pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 Idol and love you ... (Limited Edition) - 52Pt
  • [PSP]Akb1/48 idol love you ... (Limited Edition) - 43Pt
  • [PSP]Portable Another Century's Episode - 41Pt
  • [PS3]Disgaea 4 (Limited Edition) - 40pt
  • [PS3]Black Ops Call of Duty (Dubbed) - 36pt
  • [PSP]Final Mix Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep - 33pt
  • [PSP]Magical Index term (Limited Edition) - 33Pt
  • [PS3]Assassin's Creed Brotherhood - 29pt
  • [PS3]Metal Gear Solid Rising - 22pt
  •  

    Only a 7 point increase for DK... 52 points, but we have the weekend to come. The faster it gets to 100 points, the more relieved we will be!



    Nice DK, hopefully you in JP and EMEAA can move the game to 1mil WW



    Assassin's Creed Brotherhood yay!



    DKCR did so good in Americas that I don't even mind if it fails in Japan. Their loss!