By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Which game will sell the most games: Halo:Reach or Gran Turismo 5 or FFXIII

 

Which game will sell the most games: Halo:Reach or Gran Turismo 5 or FFXIII

Halo: Reach 68 39.77%
 
Gran turismo 5 94 54.97%
 
Final Fantasy XIII 9 5.26%
 
Total:171
Munkeh111 said:
Seece said:
mario64 said:

Halo is already a dying franchise, with Halo ODST selling only 4 million vs more than 10 million for Halo 3, which is a huge fall (-60% sales).

Even if Halo Reach manages to sell 6 or 7 million, it will be no match to GT5, which could sell well over 10 million lifetime.

Not even close. GT5 easily.

This post is LOL worthy.

That's like basing GT5 sales of GTP.

Well... not quite, ODST was a full priced successor to 3, even if it lacked a multiplayer mode other than firefight. Prologue (I assume you are talking about that not GT PSP {as that is on another console entirely}) was a half priced teaser

Needless to say it's a stupid thing to say it's in decline. ODST was an overpriced expansion pack that should never have been $60, but w.e.

-----------

I see much the same sort of timeline/map as COD4MW > WaW > MW2

Was COD a series "in decline" when WaW sold less? no ..

Reach will sell on par or better than Halo 3, with bigger first week sales. Predicting it's sales based on ODST's performance is weak and will get you nowhere.



 

Around the Network
mario64 said:

@Seece : I didn't know ODST was running on "Portable Xbox 360".

Halo franchise on Xbox 360 is halo franchise on Xbox 360... Last installment (ODST) sold a lot less than Halo 3 : 4,36 million vs more than 10 million. Hence my comment.

GT PSP doesn't run on PS3, so I'm not even sure what is your point.

Look up, I was talkng about GT5P

 

You really do have a lot to learn about sales .....



 

@Seece : and so do you if you don't see selling 4,36 million after selling 10 million is a bad thing. Halo has been milked too much I guess.



RPG said:
Munkeh111 said:
RPG said:
It's pretty darn obvious that Halo: Reach will sell the most with GT5 being second and FFXIII FAR away in third place. GT PSP was rubbish however I doubt that game has damaged the GT brand too much however from what we know GT5 is an absolute beast of a game. Purty game, 900 cars, weather and night racing, blah blah blah along with it being from an already big franchise ensures it will be the best selling PS3 title released on the console.

The amount of cross promotion which PD will be able to do with GT5 is amazing though, they hold so many of the licenses besides that of F1. Nascar, WRC, Super GT, IRC and hopefully a decent online will ensure this game has very good legs. Gran Turismo on the box sure won't hurt it either. :P

What was so bad about GT PSP. It lacked a campaign, but the gameplay itself is great fun, and the replays are amazing to watch. It is the best that you could expect from GT on a handheld console. In terms of sales, it is close to 1m, and should keep on selling for a while {of course, we also have no idea how much it has sold on PSN}

It was an abortion, one of epic proportions. A bits n' pieces game put together to push another abomination also known at the PSP Go, no career mode or online and an absolutely retarded game mechanic where you could only choose a few car companies each day. I have no idea at all how many copies the game has sold however I would be willing to bet that it's no where near 0.97. It did not even do 20k first NPD and has not been on the Chart Track or Media Create since it's second week. That said from the day it was announced I knew it was not going to sell well, have a look at the hate the game has on GTPlanet with 99% thinking it was the reason GT5 was not released in 2009.

In terms of strength though Halo and GT are not in the mega bracket anymore. As you said GTA, COD and the Nintendo games are much bigger so just fighting over some e-winky growth me thinks, each game will sell enough for more so meh. NSMB Wii will sell more than each of them just this year let alone the millions it sold last year so meh, fighting over crumbs here.

I will be so so bitter though if GT5 does not do at least 7 million lifetime. -__-

An abortion? Do you mean abomination?

Anyway, you know days just last 1 event? It is disapointing that you can't have any sort of progression beyond repeating tracks to allow you to try harder settings. I don't care about MP, I have never played multiplayer on PSP. I trust VGC figures enough to believe it has sold that much. Even if it hasn't sold that much in the UK, so nothing on chart track, what about continental Europe? It has been selling about 40k a week, which is not quite enough to get it in the charts, but still pretty decent. I am sure we will get figures from Polyphony Digital's shipment page soon enough



mario64 said:
@Seece : and so do you if you don't see selling 4,36 million after selling 10 million is a bad thing.

You're totally ignoring the 2 games and what they are. Halo 3 was a mega blockbuster, that was advertised through the roof, the next big installement to the franchise.

ODST was an expansion pack that had it's price rasied to $60, even had Halo 3 in front of it's name and was running off the old engine. Also go nowhere near as good reviews or marketing as Halo 3.

 

Stop ignoring logic for goodness sakes ...



 

Around the Network

Halo is Halo. Once again, no spinning and damage control will change facts.

Fact is : latest installment sold 60 % less than the installment before.

Therefore the franchise is going downhill.



mario64 said:
Halo is Halo. Once again, no spinning and damage control will change facts.

Fact is : latest installment sold 60 % less than the installment before.

Therefore the franchise is going downhill.

You can harp on as much as you want, but it isn't that black and white. Go look at my COD reference.



 

i don't see the halo franchise going downhill, but i expect Halo:reach to do less than Halo 3 because it's the 3rd installment in the console and the 4th game with Halo on :its name.

GT5 on the other way WILL be a console seller because it's the first installment on the console and just like Halo 3 moved consoles, the biggest racing game in JP,EU & US will do it too.

i expect:

GT5 9M+
H:R 7M+
FFXIII 6M+ Across Both Platforms.

Eu is GT5 territory
US is Halo territory but with a good competition from GT5.
JP is FFXIII territory with GT5 close to it.



I'm Back! - Proud owner of the best doomed handheld of all time!

I do like the fact that people think that Halo ODST won't sell any more copies



Even if it sells more copies, it's hard to believe ODST will magically go from 4.36 million to 10 million.