Heavy Rain - 88
MAG - 87
Gran Turismo 5 - 94
WKC - 83
God of War III - 93
Mod Nation Racers - 79
The Last Guardian - 87

Super Mario Galaxy 2 - 93
Metroid: Other M - 88
No More Heroes 2 - 80
Epic Mickey - 85
Sin & Punishment 2 - 75
Monster Hunter 3 - 84

360:
Alan Wake - 90
Splinter Cell Conviction - 91
Fable III - 87
Halo Reach - 92
MechWarrior - 82
Mass Effect 2 - 94
Crackdown 2 - 82

Super Mario Galaxy 2 : 93
Metroid: Other M : 89
No More Heroes 2 : 91
Epic Mickey : 94
Sin & Punishment 2: 83
Monster Hunter 3: 87

Alan Wake : 95
Splinter Cell Conviction 92
Fable III 90
Halo Reach 97
MechWarrior 83
Mass Effect 2 93
Crackdown 2 88

Heavy Rain 96
MAG 89
Gran Turismo 5 98
WKC 84
God of War III 97
Mod Nation Racers 91
The Last Guardian 96
Yakuza 3 96

(lol)

You really don't want to win.

I know little to nothing about those other games.  I will give it a shot though in a little bit.

SMG2: 95
Other M: 93
NMH2: 78
EM: 88
S&P2: 79
MH3: 81

AW: 92
SCC: 91
Fable 3: 87
Reach: 91
Mech: 82
ME2: 93
Crackdown 2: 82

HR: 86
MAG: 82
GT5: 90
WKC: 65
GOW3: 95
MNR: 85
TLG: 84

Way too optimistic, you forget that "Wii Bash" is the game of the year on many sites these days...

I'd say something like this:

Super Mario Galaxy 2: 87

Metroid Other M: 81

No More Heroes 2: 79

Epic Mickey: 72

Sin & Punishment 2: 74

Monster Hunter 3: 77

And all the games on PS3 and X360 will be 90+, because that's how things MUST be...

Forum rules are clear on what is and is not an exclusive. Locking the topic, you may remake it labeling and titling correctly.