I think Uncharted 2 (and Naughty Dog for that matter) deserved this award hands down. I played Batman and MW2; MW2 was okay, maybe pretty good, but it didn't blow me away or anything. Batman was amazing, but still cannot compete with Uncharted 2 imo. I think, regardless of who you are or what system you have a loyalty to, you can and will enjoy Uncharted 2. Give it a try people! Excellent game in EVERY way. And btw, the multiplayer is amazing, too! I actually have never enjoyed online multiplayer before (yes, I've tried MW2), but I am absolutely hooked on Uncharted 2's multiplayer.

OMG! I must buy because of t3h capz!

No!

And this is the third thread we have had about it

i thought MW2 was a pretty damn good game , it didnt blow me away but i enjoyed it

Choosing Over Batman and Uncharted 2 kills me , but i have too go with Uncharted 2