It's in the top 5 for me:
1) Super Mario Galaxy
2) Modern Warfare
3) Infamous
4) Mass Effect
5) Uncharted 2
and amazing presentation can't make up for the games core gameplay deficiency (bad AI, especially in "stealth" segments. Shotty platforming) for me to put it ahead of the other games I selected. Definitely a AMAZING game though. Leaps and bounds ahead of the original.