There was nothing wrong with Magna Carta 2, except it was an average game that took no risks. The same could be said for most Japanese Jrpg developers who seem to have lost inspiration in making rpgs. Its always the same thing, you play as a 17 year old boy who has social problems and it takes a girl to make you open up to save the world.
(yeah i know Magna carta was made by koreans when i said Jrpg)