By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Famitsu's 10 "Perfect" Games and your opinions

Where's Super Mario Galaxy?



"Success really is decided at birth, and your life will never be better than it is right now. Sorry about that."

Around the Network
Figlioni said:
Where's Super Mario Galaxy?

38/40. Extremely close.

10 10 9 9. Equivalent to a 9.5/10.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective


The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (N64) -- I got bored halfway through it. Don't agree.
Soul Calibur (DC) -- My most played fighting game ever. I loved it and obsessed over it. Agree!
Vagrant Story (PS1) -- I played this almost to the end, but got endlessly stuck on it. Not even walkthroughs could help me. 8/10
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker (GC) -- The interactive animated movie/cartoon. Loved it. Would've agreed if not for the stupidly irritating navigation parts. 9/10
Nintendogs (DS) -- Got bored with its shallow gameplay rather quickly. I can't even score it. Just erase it from my memories please.
Final Fantasy XII (PS2) -- I played it to the end for a total of 120 hours and I still wonder why I did such a masochist thing. 7/10
Super Smash Bros. Brawl (Wii) -- Chaotic and no fun for me. I have the Gamecube version but doubt this is very different. Don't agree of course.
Metal Gear Solid 4 (PS3) -- Cutscene to gameplay ratio is too unbalanced. Maybe a replay would allow me to enjoy it more. But no trophies, no luck. 7/10
428 (Wii) -- What the flying fuck is this?

Dragon Quest IX (DS) -- Haven't played it yet.

Conclusion: I only agree with regards to Soul Calibur.

 



As is common with lists such as this, I find it to be a bucket of feces to be honest.



I found a full Famitsu score database.

http://fs.finalfantasytr.com/

It doesn't give the four reviewers' scores, though, only the total.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Around the Network

Though sadly overlooked compared to other Squaresoft/Square Enix titles, Vagrant Story was and still is a fantastic game



Spedfrom said:

Nintendogs (DS) -- Got bored with its shallow gameplay rather quickly. I can't even score it. Just erase it from my memories please.

 

Maybe the game isn't for you, huh? My niece loves it, and I think this game deserves 10/10 (If you aren't in the target audience doesn't means that the game sucks or doesn't deserves 10/10).



I only really agree with OoT, my favourite game ever.

It has a great balance of difficulty, action, adventure, quests, awesome characters/story, great number of epic dungeons/bosses, music that stays stuck in your head for years (Saria's song anyone?) and the graphics were spectacular at that time... They're still very nice today, it aged well, imo.

Oh and I haven't played all the games on the list (like DQIX) but from all the games I played nothing comes close to how good OoT is.



Phoenix_Wiight said:
How can FF12, a game series that's HUGE on story, and FF12 having a terrible story, characters and characterization (IMO one of the worst ones in the series,) get a perfect score? It shouldn't.

Probably because FFXII has a lot less cutscenes than FFX which has the highest story to gameplay ratio in the entire series.  Not that I think FFXII has a terrible story or characterizations.



I only have played OoT and SSBB and I agree with both.



                       Thanks Blacksaber for the sig                  Tag:"Nintendo es toda la diversión de esta generación"