43 IGN (+ + +) - I still remember this crappy review of HS though...

15 GameTrailers
13 MetaCritic

11 Computer & Video Games

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro
10 Gamerankings

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex

8 Cheat Code Central

8 GameSpy

7 GameShark
7 Play UK Magazine

7 Sony Defence Force (---)


6 Famitsu

5 EGM Magazine (---)

2 Yahoo Games

1 X- play



Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)
4. Play Magazine (killed by Thanny)
5. Game Informer Magazine (killed by Gebx)

Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

46 IGN (+ + +)

15 GameTrailers
13 MetaCritic

11 Computer & Video Games

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro
10 Gamerankings

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex

8 Cheat Code Central

8 GameSpy

7 GameShark
7 Play UK Magazine

6 Famitsu

5 EGM Magazine

4 Sony Defence Force (---)

0 Yahoo Games (--)

0 X- play (-) 



Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)
4. Play Magazine (killed by Thanny)
5. Game Informer Magazine (killed by Gebx)
6. X - Play (killed by AsylumX)
7. Yahoo Games (killed by AsylumX)

Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

46 IGN

18 GameTrailers + + +
13 MetaCritic

11 Computer & Video Games

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro
10 Gamerankings

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex

8 Cheat Code Central

8 GameSpy

7 GameShark
7 Play UK Magazine

3 Famitsu - - - (10 for FFXII?)

2 EGM Magazine - - -

4 Sony Defence Force



Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)
4. Play Magazine (killed by Thanny)
5. Game Informer Magazine (killed by Gebx)
6. X - Play (killed by AsylumX)
7. Yahoo Games (killed by AsylumX)

Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

The List
-------------------------
46 IGN

21 GameTrailers (+++)

13 MetaCritic

11 Computer & Video Games

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro
10 Gamerankings

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex

8 Cheat Code Central
8 GameSpy

7 GameShark

6 Play UK Magazine (-)

4 Sony Defence Force

0 Famitsu (---)
0 EGM Magazine (--)


Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)
4. Play Magazine (killed by Thanny)
5. Game Informer Magazine (killed by Gebx)
6. X - Play (killed by AsylumX)
7. Yahoo Games (killed by AsylumX)
8. Famitsu (killed by Words of Wisdom)
9. EGM Magazine (killed by Words of Wisdom)


Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

bump

IGN (+)
Sony Defense Force (maximum number of '-' allowed)

The List
-------------------------
44 IGN (---)

18 GameTrailers (---)

13 Gamerankings (+++)
13 MetaCritic

11 Computer & Video Games

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex

8 Cheat Code Central
8 GameSpy

7 GameShark

6 Play UK Magazine

4 Sony Defence Force


Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)
4. Play Magazine (killed by Thanny)
5. Game Informer Magazine (killed by Gebx)
6. X - Play (killed by AsylumX)
7. Yahoo Games (killed by AsylumX)
8. Famitsu (killed by Words of Wisdom)
9. EGM Magazine (killed by Words of Wisdom)


Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

The List
-------------------------
47 IGN (+++)

18 GameTrailers

13 Gamerankings
13 MetaCritic

11 Computer & Video Games

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex

8 Cheat Code Central
8 GameSpy

7 GameShark

3 Play UK Magazine (---)

1 Sony Defence Force (---)


Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)
4. Play Magazine (killed by Thanny)
5. Game Informer Magazine (killed by Gebx)
6. X - Play (killed by AsylumX)
7. Yahoo Games (killed by AsylumX)
8. Famitsu (killed by Words of Wisdom)
9. EGM Magazine (killed by Words of Wisdom)


Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

The List
-------------------------
50 IGN (+++)

18 GameTrailers


13 MetaCritic

11 Computer & Video Games
11 Gamerankings (--)

10 Gamer 2.0
10 Game Revolution
10 GamePro

9 Gaming Target
9 Video Game Talk
9 Game Vortex

8 Cheat Code Central
8 GameSpy

7 GameShark

0 Play UK Magazine (---)

0 Sony Defence Force (-)


Eliminated
-------------------------
1. 1up (killed by dtewi)
2. Gamespot (killed by Words of Wisdom)
3. Edge Magazine (killed by Rath)
4. Play Magazine (killed by Thanny)
5. Game Informer Magazine (killed by Gebx)
6. X - Play (killed by AsylumX)
7. Yahoo Games (killed by AsylumX)
8. Famitsu (killed by Words of Wisdom)
9. EGM Magazine (killed by Words of Wisdom)
10. Sony Defence Force (killed by ssj12)
11. Play UK Magazine (killed by ssj12)


Rules
-------------------------
1. Each site/magazine starts with 10 points.
2. You can vote 3 times a day. Each vote consists of...
a. A +1 vote to one site and two -1 votes to two different sites. This may be done up to three times a day.
b. Positive votes should be marked with (+), (++), or (+++) next to the site you are voting for.
c. Negative votes should be marked with (-), (--), or (---) next to the site you are voting against.

I think we could get a farly good average for each site. Remember, people aren't nearly as ferverent about sites as they are about the games themselves. I think that will help out a lot.