That list is completely illogical. Alan Wake's draw did not seem to be its action, rather its storytelling and adventure, and I read complaints about the actual combat, so it should probably be in an adventure section
There was no nomination of R & C, because there was no PS3 platforming section, so that really should have taken the best platformer
Mass Effect 2 did not win best Xbox game, yet it won best console game, again, that does not make any sense
In the Xbox category, ODST won best shooter, but it comes second to MW 2 overall....
Again, ODST won best MP on Xbox, but L4D 2 overall...
Milo won Xbox technical excellence, Natal won overall technical excellence
How was Lords of Shadow a surprise? It was announced like over a year ago, the only surprise was how awesome it looked
And yes I am quite bitter that my baby, Uncharted 2, did not win the show