12 - Golden Sun DS
12 - Scribblenauts
12 - The Last Guardian

11 - PSP Go!
11 - Forza 3
11 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
11 - God of War 3
11 - Splinter Cell: Conviction
11 - Crackdown 2 (+)

10 - Gran Turismo 5
10 - Heavy Rain
10 - Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
10 - R* Agent
10 - Final Fantasy XIV online
10 - Gran Turismo Portable
10 - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
10 - Project Natal
10 - Halo ODST
10 - Shadow Complex
10 - Mass Effect 2
10 - Metroid: Other M
10 - Super Mario Galaxy 2
10 - Wii Sports Resort
10 - Assassin’s Creed 2
10 - Modern Warfare 2
10 - Final Fantasy XIII
10 - Metal Gear Solid: Rising
10 - Castlevania: Lords of Shadows
10 - Star Wars: The Old Republic
10 - Bayonetta
10 - Mafia 2

9 - Wii Motion Plus
9 - Alan Wake
9 - Halo Reach
9 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii
9 - Red Steel 2
9 - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles
9 - Milo
9 - PS3 Motion Controller

8 - New Zelda Talk
8 - Crysis 2
8 - Left 4 Dead 2
8 - Beatles Rock Band (-)

7 - Wii Fit Plus (-)

6 - Massive Action Game

3 - Wii Vitality Sensor (-)

Eliminated
1. Guitar Hero 5

12 - Golden Sun DS
12 - Scribblenauts
12 - The Last Guardian

11 - PSP Go!
11 - Forza 3
11 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
11 - God of War 3
11 - Splinter Cell: Conviction
11 - Crackdown 2
11 - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker (+)

10 - Gran Turismo 5
10 - Heavy Rain
10 - Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
10 - R* Agent
10 - Final Fantasy XIV online
10 - Gran Turismo Portable
10 - Project Natal
10 - Halo ODST
10 - Shadow Complex
10 - Mass Effect 2
10 - Metroid: Other M
10 - Super Mario Galaxy 2
10 - Wii Sports Resort
10 - Assassin’s Creed 2
10 - Modern Warfare 2
10 - Final Fantasy XIII
10 - Star Wars: The Old Republic
10 - Bayonetta
10 - Mafia 2

9 - Wii Motion Plus
9 - Alan Wake
9 - Halo Reach
9 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii
9 - Red Steel 2
9 - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles
9 - Milo
9 - PS3 Motion Controller
9 - Metal Gear Solid: Rising (-)
9 - Castlevania: Lords of Shadows (-)

8 - New Zelda Talk
8 - Crysis 2
8 - Left 4 Dead 2
8 - Beatles Rock Band

7 - Wii Fit Plus

6 - Massive Action Game

2 - Wii Vitality Sensor (-)


Eliminated
1. Guitar Hero 5

12 - Golden Sun DS
12 - Scribblenauts
12 - The Last Guardian

11 - PSP Go!
11 - Forza 3
11 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
11 - God of War 3
11 - Splinter Cell: Conviction
11 - Crackdown 2
11 - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
11 - Super Mario Galaxy 2(+)

10 - Gran Turismo 5
10 - Heavy Rain
10 - Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
10 - R* Agent
10 - Final Fantasy XIV online
10 - Gran Turismo Portable
10 - Halo ODST
10 - Shadow Complex
10 - Mass Effect 2
10 - Metroid: Other M
10 - Wii Sports Resort
10 - Assassin’s Creed 2
10 - Final Fantasy XIII
10 - Star Wars: The Old Republic
10 - Bayonetta
10 - Mafia 2

9 - Project Natal(-)
9 - Modern Warfare 2(-)
9 - Wii Motion Plus
9 - Alan Wake
9 - Halo Reach
9 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii
9 - Red Steel 2
9 - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles
9 - Milo
9 - PS3 Motion Controller
9 - Metal Gear Solid: Rising
9 - Castlevania: Lords of Shadows

8 - New Zelda Talk
8 - Crysis 2
8 - Beatles Rock Band

7 - Left 4 Dead 2(-)
7 - Wii Fit Plus

6 - Massive Action Game

2 - Wii Vitality Sensor


Eliminated
1. Guitar Hero 5

NinjaBlade360 said: 12 - Golden Sun DS 13 - Scribblenauts 12 - The Last Guardian 11 - PSP Go! 11 - Forza 3 11 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 11 - God of War 3 11 - Splinter Cell: Conviction 11 - Crackdown 2 11 - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker 11 - Super Mario Galaxy 2(+) 10 - Gran Turismo 5 10 - Heavy Rain 10 - Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time 10 - Final Fantasy XIV online 10 - Gran Turismo Portable 10 - Halo ODST 10 - Shadow Complex 10 - Mass Effect 2 10 - Metroid: Other M 10 - Wii Sports Resort 10 - Assassin’s Creed 2 10 - Final Fantasy XIII 10 - Star Wars: The Old Republic 10 - Bayonetta 9 - Project Natal(-) 9 - Modern Warfare 2(-) 9 - Wii Motion Plus 9 - Alan Wake 9 - Halo Reach 9 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii 9 - Red Steel 2 9 - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles 9 - PS3 Motion Controller 9 - Metal Gear Solid: Rising 9 - Castlevania: Lords of Shadows 9 - Rock* Agent 9- Mafia 2 8 - New Zelda Talk 8 - Crysis 2 8 - Beatles Rock Band 8 - Milo 7 - Left 4 Dead 2(-) 7 - Wii Fit Plus 6 - Massive Action Game 2 - Wii Vitality Sensor Eliminated 1. Guitar Hero 5

 

@ misterd

It's a hell of a lot easier when you put signs at the ones you changed

13 - Scribblenauts

12 - Golden Sun DS
12 - The Last Guardian

11 - PSP Go!
11 - Forza 3
11 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
11 - God of War 3
11 - Splinter Cell: Conviction
11 - Crackdown 2
11 - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
11 - Super Mario Galaxy 2

10 - Modern Warfare 2 (+)
10 - Gran Turismo 5
10 - Heavy Rain
10 - Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
10 - Final Fantasy XIV online
10 - Gran Turismo Portable
10 - Halo ODST
10 - Mass Effect 2
10 - Metroid: Other M
10 - Wii Sports Resort
10 - Assassin’s Creed 2
10 - Final Fantasy XIII
10 - Star Wars: The Old Republic
10 - Bayonetta

9 - Shadow Complex (-)
9 - Project Natal
9 - Wii Motion Plus
9 - Alan Wake
9 - Halo Reach
9 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii
9 - Red Steel 2
9 - PS3 Motion Controller
9 - Metal Gear Solid: Rising
9 - Castlevania: Lords of Shadows
9 - Rock* Agent
9 - Mafia 2

8 - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles (-)
8 - Crysis 2
8 - Beatles Rock Band
8 - Milo

7 - New Zelda Talk (-)
7 - Left 4 Dead 2
7 - Wii Fit Plus

6 - Massive Action Game

2 - Wii Vitality Sensor


Eliminated
1. Guitar Hero 5

Last: Rainbird (Please keep this, it helps to see when someone is skipped)

13 - Scribblenauts
13 - Golden Sun DS (+)

12 - The Last Guardian

11 - PSP Go!
11 - Forza 3
11 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
11 - God of War 3
11 - Splinter Cell: Conviction
11 - Crackdown 2
11 - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
11 - Super Mario Galaxy 2

10 - Modern Warfare 2
10 - Gran Turismo 5
10 - Heavy Rain
10 - Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
10 - Final Fantasy XIV online
10 - Gran Turismo Portable
10 - Halo ODST
10 - Mass Effect 2
10 - Metroid: Other M
10 - Wii Sports Resort
10 - Assassin’s Creed 2
10 - Final Fantasy XIII
10 - Star Wars: The Old Republic
10 - Bayonetta

9 - Shadow Complex
9 - Project Natal
9 - Wii Motion Plus
9 - Alan Wake
9 - Halo Reach
9 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii
9 - Red Steel 2
9 - PS3 Motion Controller
9 - Metal Gear Solid: Rising
9 - Castlevania: Lords of Shadows
9 - Rock* Agent
9 - Mafia 2

8 - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles
8 - Milo

7 - Beatles Rock Band (-)
7 - Crysis 2 (-)
7 - New Zelda Talk
7 - Left 4 Dead 2
7 - Wii Fit Plus

6 - Massive Action Game

1 - Wii Vitality Sensor (-)


Eliminated
1. Guitar Hero 5

Last: Rainbird (Please keep this, it helps to see when someone is skipped)

Yeah that’s right it’s an elimination game. With E3 over, which thing do you rate as the biggest of the convention?

Rules are simple. Each game or hardware (which I will refer to as things :p) starts with 10 points. When you post, copy/paste the currently existing list from the last post, then add 1 point to one thing and remove three points from three different things. Please re-organize the things as the order changes (for instance, if you vote for one and its number rises from 11 to 12, place it above all the 11-ranked things).

You may vote once every two hours.

Presently, there are 47 things deemed worthy. As they are eliminated, add them to the end of the list in the "ELIMINATED/INSTANT FAIL" section, one after the next, in paragraph form, numbered and separated by commas.

*Note: I’ve selected 47 things only to not make the list too long. I’ve tried to make the list as fair as possible to hopefully make everyone happy. If you’re disappointed the in your opinion biggest game is not on the list, then blame my poor education.

So, to recap. RULES: Post 1x every 2 hours. Add 1 point to a thing; subtract 3 from three things (NOT the same thing). When a thing is eliminated, add it to the list at the end. And keep it fun.

13 - Scribblenauts
13 - Golden Sun DS
12 - The Last Guardian
11 - PSP Go!
11 - Forza 3
11 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
11 - God of War 3
11 - Splinter Cell: Conviction
11 - Crackdown 2
11 - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
11 - Super Mario Galaxy 2
10 - Modern Warfare 2
10 - Gran Turismo 5
10 - Heavy Rain
10 - Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
10 - Final Fantasy XIV online
10 - Gran Turismo Portable
10 - Halo ODST
10 - Mass Effect 2
10 - Metroid: Other M
10 - Wii Sports Resort
10 - Assassin’s Creed 2
10 - Final Fantasy XIII
10 - Star Wars: The Old Republic
10 - Bayonetta
9 - Shadow Complex
9 - Project Natal
9 - Wii Motion Plus
9 - Alan Wake
9 - Halo Reach
9 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii
9 - Red Steel 2
9 - PS3 Motion Controller
9 - Metal Gear Solid: Rising
9 - Castlevania: Lords of Shadows
9 - Rock* Agent
9 - Mafia 2
8 - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles
7 - Milo (-)
7 - Beatles Rock Band
7 - Crysis 2
7 - New Zelda Talk
7 - Wii Fit Plus
7 - Massive Action Game (+)
6 - Left 4 Dead 2 (-)

Eliminated
1. Guitar Hero 5
2. Wii Vitality Sensor

@ JEDE3

You only took points away from two things and you screwed up the formatting...

Last JEDE3

14 - Scribblenauts (+)

13 - Golden Sun DS

12 - The Last Guardian

11 - PSP Go!
11 - Forza 3
11 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
11 - God of War 3
11 - Splinter Cell: Conviction
11 - Crackdown 2
11 - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
11 - Super Mario Galaxy 2

10 - Modern Warfare 2
10 - Gran Turismo 5
10 - Heavy Rain
10 - Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
10 - Gran Turismo Portable
10 - Halo ODST
10 - Mass Effect 2
10 - Metroid: Other M
10 - Wii Sports Resort
10 - Assassin’s Creed 2
10 - Final Fantasy XIII
10 - Star Wars: The Old Republic
10 - Bayonetta

9 - Shadow Complex
9 - Final Fantasy XIV online (-)
9 - Project Natal
9 - Wii Motion Plus
9 - Alan Wake
9 - Halo Reach
9 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii
9 - Red Steel 2
9 - PS3 Motion Controller
9 - Metal Gear Solid: Rising
9 - Castlevania: Lords of Shadows
9 - Mafia 2

8 - Rock* Agent (-)
8 - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles
8 - Milo

7 - Beatles Rock Band
7 - Crysis 2
7 - New Zelda Talk
7 - Wii Fit Plus

6 - Massive Action Game (-)
6 - Left 4 Dead 2

Eliminated
1. Guitar Hero 5
2. Wii Vitality Sensor

Rainbird said: @ JEDE3 You only took points away from two things and you screwed up the formatting...

I read the rules and added another -.