which looked more impressive, from a gamer point of view?

Im going to Say the Precision Motion Control, cause theres only so much you can do with set paths and no controller with Natal.

and Sony's was a prototype with Perfect accuracy, buttons, and an analog stick on each controller.

Theres just more you can do with Precision, that atm you cannot with Natal.

BTW PS3 Eye toy does track body movements as well, as shown at e3 when the guy was kneeling and whatnot.

I'm sorry dude, but we have a number of threads discussing this already. We don't need another.

locked.

Uh.....Natal is revolutionary, anyone who disagrees is a blind fanboy. Natal is the next step in video interactivity. The Milo demonstration was mind blowing.