It was a tie for me all because of the three biggest surprises

MS: Halo Reach prequel/ NATAL

Ninty: Metroid Other M/Golden Sun DS

Sony: FFXIV/God of War Demo

Easily Sony.

Guys, Sony would have won hands down if there was no leaks. Trust me.

Ninty

They easily won even with the leaks.

Microsoft won EASILY, go and check other gaming sites, all saying the same, ign, gamespot, eurogamer, cvg etc,

Seems to be Microsoft --> Nintendo --> Sony

nintendo

Nintendo was plain vanilla, but a very high quality vanilla. Simple. Sweet.

Microsoft gave us a little spice, but you end up thinking, "These are habaneros from Atlantis? I don't think habaneros grow there."

Sony Bought a pie from a store, claimed they made it, then ate it all in front of us to destroy the evidence. It was a perfectly good pie, but nothing we haven't seen a thousand times.

I think the vitality sensor was just to throw off Microsoft and Sony, though it might have some nifty real world applications. I think something like that could be useful in psychiatry.

Sony

I think Microsoft had the most important NEW games, with that new Halo game, and overall the best linup of "new" games.

However, I think Nintendo had the TOP new games.

I think FFXIV is an online MMORPG and I don't care one bit about that.

The PSP, however, had a hell of a show.

Threeway tie between Wii, 360, and PSP.