I'm going to the store in around ten minutes.  I want a scary game.  Alone in the dark or fear 2?

anyone...?

i would love for atari to send me my money back for alone in the dark, dont make my mistake

if you can go retro at the store a scary pc game is system shock 2

i tried demo of fear 2, seemed good

FEAR2 by far in both scare factor and gameplay factor. Never consider the new Alone in the Dark, I was a fan of the old games as well, but the new one is just ugh >

alone in the dark is terrible, all of his versions, fear 2 is good, if you havent played the first fear that would be my choice, it should be cheaper by now.

F.E.A.R. 2 is the way to go. WAYYYY better than alone in the dark.

other options are:
Dead Space
Silent Hill: Homecoming
Siren: Blood Curse (PSN)

F.E.A.R. 2 by a million.

Dead Space is also, imho, a great game.

also dead space or left 4 dead, both are beter than your two choices (in general)

Fuck. I bought Alone in the dark. Back to the store.