Quantcast
Locked: IGN Madworld review..

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - IGN Madworld review..

My call: 8.0 -- too short, little replay value. Same thing they gave Heavenly Sword, and for the same reason.

8.0 tops, actually, since they tend to knock Wii games just for being SD.



 

Around the Network
Procrastinato said:

My call: 8.0 -- too short, little replay value. Same thing they gave Heavenly Sword, and for the same reason.

8.0 tops, actually, since they tend to knock Wii games just for being SD.

IGN gave Heavenly Sword a 7.0, and not just because it was short.

Inevitably, everything in that genre gets compared to God of War...



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

gamrReview - Arthur Kabrick | My All-Time Top 50 | 2013 Metascores

                                        

And people dare to say they dont care about reviews when we have a thread for predictions of a review score by some gaming site. Duh.

OT: if they said it's their goty contender then it's definitely 9.0+



Kantor said:
Procrastinato said:

My call: 8.0 -- too short, little replay value. Same thing they gave Heavenly Sword, and for the same reason.

8.0 tops, actually, since they tend to knock Wii games just for being SD.

IGN gave Heavenly Sword a 7.0, and not just because it was short.

Inevitably, everything in that genre gets compared to God of War...

 

Hmm you're right.  I could swear it was 8.0, but I just looked and its 7.0.  HS was better than 7.0, in my book, I guess I painted my own picture, after calling BS on IGN or something.

I kinda think Madworld will score higher than 7.0, if its gameplay is at all decent.  I think it'll sell like crap, but I feel confident it'll score at least 7.5, and probably closer to 8.0.



 

I don't give a shit about IGN. Long Live Next Generation

 

On Topic:  They will probably give it something between a 8-9.



Around the Network
super_etecoon said:
man...this thread title tricks me every time.

-1 for paperdiego.

 

)= 

sorry didnt mean to make the title turn out the wat it did.

 

to bad we cant edit titles.

 



hello how are you.

Kantor said:
Procrastinato said:

My call: 8.0 -- too short, little replay value. Same thing they gave Heavenly Sword, and for the same reason.

8.0 tops, actually, since they tend to knock Wii games just for being SD.

IGN gave Heavenly Sword a 7.0, and not just because it was short.

Inevitably, everything in that genre gets compared to God of War...

 

so true.

i never beat HS but i played through parts with a buddy of mine and it seemed much better than God of war.

 

.. at least in my book.

 

way better than a 7.0

 



hello how are you.

Paperdiego said:
Kantor said:
Procrastinato said:

My call: 8.0 -- too short, little replay value. Same thing they gave Heavenly Sword, and for the same reason.

8.0 tops, actually, since they tend to knock Wii games just for being SD.

IGN gave Heavenly Sword a 7.0, and not just because it was short.

Inevitably, everything in that genre gets compared to God of War...


so true.

i never beat HS but i played through parts with a buddy of mine and it seemed much better than God of war.


.. at least in my book.


way better than a 7.0


How is Heavenly Sword better than God of War in any way? You have 500 enemies surrounding you at any given time, strafing around like idiots, Nariko fights like she has a metal rod down her back, the story is pathetic, and the game is some six hours long. Also, it has lag.

It's better than Ninja Gaiden, imo.

Although maybe I shouldn't be judging it based on the demo...



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

gamrReview - Arthur Kabrick | My All-Time Top 50 | 2013 Metascores

                                        

Kantor said:
Paperdiego said:
Kantor said:
Procrastinato said:

My call: 8.0 -- too short, little replay value. Same thing they gave Heavenly Sword, and for the same reason.

8.0 tops, actually, since they tend to knock Wii games just for being SD.

IGN gave Heavenly Sword a 7.0, and not just because it was short.

Inevitably, everything in that genre gets compared to God of War...

 

so true.

i never beat HS but i played through parts with a buddy of mine and it seemed much better than God of war.

 

.. at least in my book.

 

way better than a 7.0

 

How is Heavenly Sword better than God of War in any way? You have 500 enemies surrounding you at any given time, strafing around like idiots, Nariko fights like she has a metal rod down her back, the story is pathetic, and the game is some six hours long. Also, it has lag.

It's better than Ninja Gaiden, imo.

Although maybe I shouldn't be judging it based on the demo...

 

like i said, i only played parts but the parts i did play i thought were better tha god of war.

 

i didnt own a ps3 at the time ( i just got mine november of last year) but if i had one i might have bought the game and beaten it.

 

right now my time is still occipied by call of duty 4 ( which i got free with my ps3 and i think its almost the best game of this gen. imo mario galaxy is better)



hello how are you.

9.1




remember... 9.1