I finally got it, which is wierd because I got a Wii after playing Wii golf.  I loved tiger on 360,but this is an example of a Wii control game that you can't go back on.  It's even got online.  Just started playing it this afternoon,and am diving into career mode.  Nothing beats actually swinging to play a golf game.  It's refreshing to have the loud 360 off for a bit for a change, been a while.  But with the options and stuff going on, I think this will take forever.

    The graphics are better on 360 yes, but this reminds me of tiger 03-06 on old xbox, and thats not bad.  Coupled with the control its a game I can't go back on.

    How are the other all play games?  are they this good?  speaking more on motion controls, online, and career mode.

*Wii fanboy hat on*

All-Play games are superior in all regards to 360/PS3 versions. Also, due to the rock bottom cost of development on the Wii, All-Play games should be priced around $19.99, new, in the future.

Don't ever go back. You should get the football and basketball attachments for your Wiimote, for the full experience.

*hat off*

Honestly, Tiger Woods is it, due to the nature of the controls. The other All-Play games don't really come close, since there isn't really a natural match for the motion controller in the gameplay, unlike golf.  If there was an All-Play baseball game, it might end up decent, however.

a basketball game where you shoot would be neat but hard to do, maybe on the free throws.

too bad to hear they're not that good.

I have Madden 09 all-play and it is great.  Motion works   not great  but not bad either. Online is excellent   dont even need friend codes to get to know people. I have never played Madden before but this is the best you can get on Wii for shure. Cant compare to any other console when I havent tried any

Why isn't there a Tennis All-Play?

There will be a Tennis game from EA this year. Who knows maybe it will be a Tennis All-play

All-Play Tennis might be pretty fun. I hope it has a career mode.

Man, I've wanted a beefier golf game on my Wii ever since playing Wii Sports Golf (it's my favorite Wii Sports mini-game by far... lots of fun!), and Tiger Woods '09 All-Play looked to fulfill that need... and then Nintendo announced WiiMotion+. I'm not a huge sports gamer, so I'm really only looking to buy one golf game during this generation.

I know that Tiger Woods '10 will have a really awesome golfing experience with 1:1 controls... and I can't wait. >_<

Glad to know that you're enjoying the game.

Madden is great, Tiger is better, NBA and NCAA Football both not so much. The Tennis game supporting WM+ will hopefully be good but no one's actually seen anything on it yet.

PES2008 demonstrated that you could do quite a bit with the Wiimote to improve a sports game without resorting to flailing the Wiimote around ... Personally, I would love it if EA took those controls to the next level with NHL 2010 for the Wii.