I am a curious one. I just have to know everything. I'm also a Smash Brothers fans.

Sakurai (the game's lead designer) said that the characters added must make people want to play the game. So here is the thing: I will post a list of characters and you guys say how much the character would want to make you play the game or not (from 0-10). If the characters makes you want to play, rate them a 10. If the characters would make you not want to play the game, give them a 0. 5 is indifferent. I'm sure you guys can figure out the rest. So, will you amuse my curiousity.

• Toad (Super Mario)
• Waluigi (Super Mario)
• Bowser Jr. (Super Mario)
• Waluigi (Super Mario)
• Paper Mario (Super Mario)
• Dr. Mario (Super Mario)
• Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong)
• King K. Rool (Donkey Kong)
• Midna (Legend of Zelda)
• Tetra/Toon Zelda (Legend of Zelda)
• Ridley(Metroid)
• Dark Samus (Metroid)
• Helpers (Kirby)
• Krystal (Starfox)
• Slippy (Starfox)
• Mewtwo (Pokemon)
• Any Pokemon character
• Samurai Gohor (F-Zero)
• Black Shadow (F-Zero)
• Any F-Zero Character
• Roy (Fire Emblem)
• Any Fire Emblem character
• Mona (Warioware)
• Ashely (Warioware)
• Kat &Ana (Warioware)
• Infantry (Advance Wars)
• Any Advance Wars character
• Little Mac(Punch-Out)
• Takamaru (Nazo no Murasamejō)
• Sakupon (Joy Mech Fight)
• Saki (Sin & Punishment)
• Issa (Sin & Punishment 2)
• Issac (Golden Sun)
• Felix (Golden Sun)
• Bald Karate Man (Rhythm Heaven)
• Mii (Wii)
• Mega Man
• Any Sonic character
• Any third party character

So I hope I didn't bog you guys down. I skipped a lot of third party characters since the list was long enough as is. It was long becuase I was try to get every character that had some mention. Let me know if I missed any character importaint.

Oh, and if you are confused, it's all about if the character would interest you, if the character interest you or not. Thanks in advance.

02 * Toad (Super Mario)
04 * Waluigi (Super Mario)
08 * Bowser Jr. (Super Mario)
08 * Paper Mario (Super Mario)
06 * Dr. Mario (Super Mario)
02 * Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong)
07 * King K. Rool (Donkey Kong)
08 * Midna (Legend of Zelda)
08 * Tetra/Toon Zelda (Legend of Zelda)
09 * Ridley(Metroid)
10 * Dark Samus (Metroid)
05 * Helpers (Kirby)
08 * Krystal (Starfox)
02 * Slippy (Starfox)
07 * Mewtwo (Pokemon)
07 * Any Pokemon character
03 * Samurai Gohor (F-Zero)
03 * Black Shadow (F-Zero)
03 * Any F-Zero Character
05 * Roy (Fire Emblem)
07 * Any Fire Emblem character
03 * Mona (Warioware)
03 * Ashely (Warioware)
03 * Kat &Ana (Warioware)
03 * Infantry (Advance Wars)
04 * Any Advance Wars character
06 * Little Mac(Punch-Out)
?? * Takamaru (Nazo no Murasamejō)
?? * Sakupon (Joy Mech Fight)
?? * Saki (Sin & Punishment)
?? * Issa (Sin & Punishment 2)
?? * Issac (Golden Sun)
?? * Felix (Golden Sun)
?? * Bald Karate Man (Rhythm Heaven)
10 * Mega Man
06 * Any Sonic character
08 * Any third party character

Hows that?

__XBrawlX__ said: Hows that?

Good, thanks :)

 

Come on people!

• 5   Toad (Super Mario)
• 7   Waluigi (Super Mario)
• 5   Bowser Jr. (Super Mario)
• 7?   Waluigi (Super Mario)
• 4   Paper Mario (Super Mario)
• 3   Dr. Mario (Super Mario)
• 8   Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong)
• 7   King K. Rool (Donkey Kong)
• 6   Midna (Legend of Zelda)
• ?   Tetra/Toon Zelda (Legend of Zelda)
• 10   Ridley(Metroid)
• 5   Dark Samus (Metroid)
• 4   Helpers (Kirby)
• 7   Krystal (Starfox)
• 5   Slippy (Starfox)
• 10  Mewtwo(Pokemon)
• 7  Any Pokemon character
• 6  Samurai Gohor (F-Zero)
• ?   Black Shadow (F-Zero)
• 6   Any F-Zero Character
• 6.5   Roy (Fire Emblem)
• 8   Any Fire Emblem character
• ?   Mona (Warioware)
• ?   Ashely (Warioware)
• ?   Kat &Ana (Warioware)
• 7   Infantry (Advance Wars)
• 7   Any Advance Wars character
• 8   Little Mac(Punch-Out)
• ?   Takamaru (Nazo no Murasamejō)
• ?   Sakupon (Joy Mech Fight)
• ?   Saki (Sin & Punishment)
• ?   Issa (Sin & Punishment 2)
• 5   Issac (Golden Sun)
• ?   Felix (Golden Sun)
• ?   Bald Karate Man (Rhythm Heaven)
• 7   Mega Man
• 8   Any Sonic character
• 8   Any third party character
• Billions!1!1  Okami

Although, a deep change or something really new in regards to the basic gameplay is probably more needed than 40 more characters.  Brawl is great, but a fourth one is going to need to avoid stagnating.

Add Viewtiful Joe and I may even buy the next Smash Brothers.

Smashchu2 said: I am a curious one. I just have to know everything. I'm also a Smash Brothers fans. Sakurai (the game's lead designer) said that the characters added must make people want to play the game. So here is the thing: I will post a list of characters and you guys say how much the character would want to make you play the game or not (from 0-10). If the characters makes you want to play, rate them a 10. If the characters would make you not want to play the game, give them a 0. 5 is indifferent. I'm sure you guys can figure out the rest. So, will you amuse my curiousity. Toad (Super Mario) 5 - what would his moves be? Waluigi (Super Mario) 6 - could be good for some lols, but we have Wario for that Bowser Jr. (Super Mario) 4 - He would be a clone of bowser, one of the characters with the least playtime on my game Paper Mario (Super Mario) 6- Would be cool I spose, but perhaps better as a costume than a character Dr. Mario (Super Mario) 3 - He just took up space and made it more likely for mario to come up on random Dr Mario (as a costume) 7 - Why not?? Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong) 5 - There's enough kong's already King K. Rool (Donkey Kong) 6 - Don't know much about him, he seems pretty cool though Midna (Legend of Zelda) 9 - On the back of wolf link :D Tetra/Toon Zelda (Legend of Zelda) 6 - Don't really see much to be gained Ridley(Metroid) 10 - It's ridley, need I say more? Dark Samus (Metroid) 9 - Metroid needs more representation Helpers (Kirby) - Dunno who that is Krystal (Starfox) 7 If she had a unique moveset, 3 if she was a wolf/falco/fox clone Slippy (Starfox) 5 - He's a douche Mewtwo (Pokemon) 7.5 - He was cool Any Pokemon character Depends on who. But I think pokemon has enough representatives Samurai Gohor (F-Zero) 8 If they think of some good moves for him Black Shadow (F-Zero) 8 If they think of some good moves for him Any F-Zero Character 4 - They are clearly not going to put any other character ahead of the two above, and 3 F-Zero characters would be enough Roy (Fire Emblem) 10 - Whilst Ike is incredibly badass, I still miss Roy Any Fire Emblem character 9 - So many awesome characters in those games Mona (Warioware) 5 - Who?? Ashely (Warioware) 5 - Who?? Kat &Ana (Warioware) 5 - Who?? Infantry (Advance Wars) Not worth considering. There will never be a conventional gun in Smash Bros (Sakuri said so) Any Advance Wars character 9 - Could be cool, could even be an interesting character along the lines of Captain Olimar. You play as the commander and summon various troops Little Mac(Punch-Out) 7 - Sounds good, never played the game so I can't get too excited Takamaru (Nazo no Murasamejō) Who? Sakupon (Joy Mech Fight) Who? Saki (Sin & Punishment) 8 - Who? The game looks cool though Issa (Sin & Punishment 2) 8 - Who? The game looks cool though Issac (Golden Sun) 10 - I would die a happy man if this happened Felix (Golden Sun) 10 - I would die a happy man if this happened Bald Karate Man (Rhythm Heaven) Who? Mii (Wii) 7 - Could be amusing I spose (as long as they don't ban Hitler from online) Mega Man 10 - awesome Any Sonic character Tails = 10, Knuckles = 9, Anyone else = 4 Any third party character How specific :P So I hope I didn't bog you guys down. I skipped a lot of third party characters since the list was long enough as is. It was long becuase I was try to get every character that had some mention. Let me know if I missed any character importaint. Oh, and if you are confused, it's all about if the character would interest you, if the character interest you or not. Thanks in advance.

Hmmm, sorry if there is some confusions. Some of the characters (like Sukapon) are ones that have been suggested by Japanese fans, but are Japan-only games. The Wikipedia links should tell you a little about the game.

The Karate Guy is from Rhythm Heaven (Tengoku) and will be coming this year.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bNrQnOVUIwc&feature=related

Hope this helps a little. Better Link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KhRs7gC5DZ0&feature=related

2* Toad (Super Mario)
9* Waluigi (Super Mario)
5* Bowser Jr. (Super Mario)
?* Waluigi (Super Mario)
4* Paper Mario (Super Mario)
8* Dr. Mario (Super Mario)
1* Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong)
4* King K. Rool (Donkey Kong)
7* Midna (Legend of Zelda)
9* Tetra/Toon Zelda (Legend of Zelda)
0* Ridley(Metroid)
3* Dark Samus (Metroid)
4* Helpers (Kirby)
4* Krystal (Starfox)
1* Slippy (Starfox)
8* Mewtwo (Pokemon)
10* Any Pokemon character
4* Samurai Gohor (F-Zero)
5* Black Shadow (F-Zero)
6* Any F-Zero Character
9* Roy (Fire Emblem)
7* Any Fire Emblem character
3* Mona (Warioware)
10* Ashely (Warioware)
6* Kat &Ana (Warioware)
5* Infantry (Advance Wars)
5* Any Advance Wars character
8* Little Mac(Punch-Out)
5* Takamaru (Nazo no Murasamejō)
5* Sakupon (Joy Mech Fight)
5* Saki (Sin & Punishment)
5* Issa (Sin & Punishment 2)
8* Issac (Golden Sun)
5* Felix (Golden Sun)
5* Bald Karate Man (Rhythm Heaven)
9* Mii (Wii)
9* Mega Man
100!* Any Sonic character
10 * Any third party character

1* Toad (Super Mario)
2* Waluigi (Super Mario)
2* Bowser Jr. (Super Mario)
2* Waluigi (Super Mario)
3* Paper Mario (Super Mario)
3* Dr. Mario (Super Mario)
3* Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong)
3* King K. Rool (Donkey Kong)
4* Midna (Legend of Zelda)
3* Tetra/Toon Zelda (Legend of Zelda)
1* Ridley(Metroid)
theres a costume already :P* Dark Samus (Metroid)
wth* Helpers (Kirby)
4* Krystal (Starfox)
2* Slippy (Starfox)
7* Mewtwo (Pokemon)
4* Any Pokemon character
7* Samurai Gohor (F-Zero)
5* Black Shadow (F-Zero)
5* Any F-Zero Character
4* Roy (Fire Emblem)
10(Lyn)* Any Fire Emblem character
wth* Mona (Warioware)
1* Ashely (Warioware)
1* Kat &Ana (Warioware)
1* Infantry (Advance Wars)
1* Any Advance Wars character
3* Little Mac(Punch-Out)
wth* Takamaru (Nazo no Murasamejō)
wth* Sakupon (Joy Mech Fight)
wth* Saki (Sin & Punishment)
wth* Issa (Sin & Punishment 2)
10* Issac (Golden Sun)
5* Felix (Golden Sun)
wth* Bald Karate Man (Rhythm Heaven)
0* Mii (Wii)
7* Mega Man
0(Sonic alone is fine)* Any Sonic character
depends* Any third party character